Cole's Public House

Everything!! The food was very good. We love the ambiance. The look and feel is great. Anna waited on us again because we asked for her. She was great as before.

Wish I had pictures to show how badly they ripped me off. Went there for a birthday day party for mother. On 1-22-25 at 5:30 pm. I along with my brother in law got the flank steak for $32.00 and it was so small. We both got 6 pieces of steak 1 1/2 inch long and 1/2 inch thick and a mound of mash potatoes for $32.00. Ohh ya and a side salad. It looked like they ran out of the flank steak and just split one between the two of us this place should be ashamed of themselves for doing that I would have complained but it was mom's birthday dinner. For $32.00 I expected a hole steak not one split between another person. The prime rib did look outstanding and the service was good but I did not expect to be taken advantage of like that just sad

Great meal, super service by Ryan, and a fun atmosphere! I only photographed the starter- stuffed mushrooms- but everything was also beautifully and delicious! I had a fab butternut squash/kale/walnut salad with a side of fries and it was one of my favorite salads! Meatloaf and mashed potatoes was also a big hit!

I was very impressed. We went early when they were not busy since I have 4 kids. They where super nice and even made us hand made lemonade when the machine went down. Food was delicious and worth the extra money they charged for it. I want to mention the kids meals where like adult portions and higher quality chicken, Mac and cheese, etc then normal kids meals but still kids meal prices! Great place, must go if your in the area. The ratittue, meat loaf, and gnocchi where delicious. The brussel sprouts where a huge hit with the kids!

Went to Cole's Public House in Amherst first time there and will be returning. Very nice place good atmosphere and ambience. It was early and not too crowded but found out they had two entrances one on Park Ave and another off Main Street. Staff was friendly and helpful. I had the wild boar gnocchi and a side salad which was delicious and my brother had the apple Brie burger and fries with a very nice smoke garlic aioli. They nice list of cocktails, beer as well as nice choices of spirits. Reasonably priced.

This place is great. The drink selection and drink menu is one of the best I've seen. There were a half dozen cocktails that I was eager to try. The menu was also great. Everything I saw come out of the kitchen was prepared with love. Wish I lived closer and could go back often.

Apple Brie Burger We both got this burger and soo good. Wish this new find wasn't almost 4 hours away from home. The truffle fries were perfectly seasoned, the truffle did not over power. Their fresh brewed iced tea was so good. Their draft, wine & cocktail was extensive and one martini that walked by look very good.

We stopped here on a Friday night and got right in. The ambiance of the place is great and the staff were very friendly. I had the Elk and my husband had the cab beef tenderloin. Both were very good and cooked perfectly. Even though it is a bit of a drive to get there we will be coming back.

Christmas barFor the holidays they decorated the one half of the restaurant in a festive vibe of Christmas lights, trees, poinsettias, Santa statues and other holiday decor. I highly recommend making reservations and letting them know what side you prefer. Making reservations is easy and they even send text and email reminders. They even had an acoustic music playing a mix of Christmas songs and alternative rock songs. As always the food was great!

Hada reservation for the Xmas room. Decorated nice, but no Xmas music or movies, just football. We came for the Xmas, not the sports. Asked if it could be changed, the bartender tried, but couldn't figure out how to turn on a Xmas movie for us. Food was ok, but they served my burger before they brought my soup. Took 25 minutes to get my first drink, after that they were pretty good about service. Really mostly disappointed that we didn't get the full Xmas room experience, which was the whole point. If we wanted just a sports bar, we could have gone anywhere.