Coffaro's Pizza

Updated review...After several years of prioritizing other local pizza places, I've returned as a customer. I've eaten Coffaro's several times over those years at friends houses, and it's been good at times but still somewhat inconsistent. However, I believe it's been good at least 75% of the time, and when it's good, it's damn good. I will continue to say this pizza is best consumed after a few adult beverages, and I do not recommend Coffaro's to fans of high quality pizza and toppings. Coffaro's is a good place for cheaper "crowd pleasing" pizza that won't break the bank.

Pepperoni Pizza was excellent. I didn't care much for the "hot" wings. I was in the mood for wings & they were disappointing .. not hot or much flavor to them. I look forward to getting other items on the menu next time. The menu looks amazing.We will visit again.

As far a pizza goes it went fantastic.However for the area I'm in, and the pizzeria's around...this is the best! When you have a Little Caesars, and Pizza Hut to compare with this is the $hit. The salad was great and actually pretty sizable, and the shareable were regular American type stuff.The town is really nice, and the area is full of nice people which helps. The outside is very picturesque of your traditional Hallmark towns. The inside of this pizzeria is very very small with one table and two chairs, and no bathroom. 6/10

Used to be good until they hired young'uns. Now pizza are cold and/or burnt. Trust me take your business elsewhere

Great food and excellent service. Their subs are the best. Italian sub is my fave. Delivery available and drivers are always courtious and on time. Can't say much else. You need to check this place out for yourself.

This is the best pizza in town! Has the most amazing crust! Time on delivery is usually quicker than estimated!

I wanted to like this place but the calzone and breadsticks were not good at all. The calzone was huge but barely any cheese and a ton of bread, it was too overwhelming and the breadsticks were not flavorful whatsoever. The best part was the garlic sauce.

Horrible wings. gave wrong sauce on them. called to get new order and they refused. pizza was also cold at pickup.

Always accurate, fast delivery and reasonably priced. Easy, quick ordering. I've been buying pizza & subs here for years and they never disappoint.

Ordered for pick up was told 20-25 mins. When I went to pick up it was not ready. Paid and waited an additional 30 minutes. Food still not done. Asked to get refunded for what was not ready and was told no one there knew how to operate the register to do a refund. I asked if there was a manager that could do it. Was told she didn't know his name. After I asked repeatedly for assistance the man finally answered me and was very rude when returning the money for the stuff that I didn't get. I waited over an hour for an Italian hoagie and jalapeno poppers. Don't waste you time. The food is not that great food the horrible service.