Casamel's Pizza

Delicious. Perfectly size for one person. Ordered through Ubereats last minute and still got good product.

The pizza is amazing but wow delivery was way behind tonight.. ordered pizza at 6:34pm with a delivery projection of about 45min to 1hr... let's just say our pizza didn't arrive until 9:02pm.I called to check in at 8:12 to check the status of our pizza and we were told the driver had car issue and had left with our delivery... called back 2 min later and offered to pick the pizza up. We were assured that it would be here within 30 min and that food was fresh.Manager stated it takes 7min for pizza to go through oven and then coming straight here.. clerk stated it's already on the way.... So yea almost an hr later and 1 annoyed mom later our pizza arrived... Never ordering delivery again.. don't be hungry or order at lunch time if you want your food by dinner

Tonight's our last night in CLE on this trip. We really wanted some authentic Cleveland pizza. The kind we used to get before all the chains took over, Like we had growing up here. We searched through Yelp, found Casamel's and ordered a supreme and some wings. They did not disappoint. First, the crust was just right, medium thickness with crispy edges. Not like that cardboard you get in NY. All of the toppings were great especially the sausage. It was in chunks not crumbles. The wings were perfect with the C-town rub. I wish we could get this pizza in FL. Next time we are in town we will be back.

This used to be my go-to pizza place when I lived in the neighborhood. Nothing fancy, just great traditional pizza made fresh with quality ingredients.

I went into cozumel's pizza and these people knocked my socks off gave me great service at the door made things flexible for me payment. Maddy , and everyone else on the night shift gave, above average service and and a quality product the only downside is that there was no bathroom for customers, and no juice or tea option to drink, but if you're not hung up on that and you like a quality product or quality service this is the place to go thanks for a great experience.

Casamel's Pizza supplied the first meal in my new house in Old Brooklyn. The person who took my order was friendly and allowed us to just barely eek in an order for delivery before they stopped delivery for the night.Earlier than we anticipated, a classic cheese pie arrived at our door step piping hot. I especially loved the sauce, which was both sweet and deeply tomato-y. We've had an opportunity since to compare this pizza to other area pizza delivery and so far Casamel's is winning. Will definitely be ordering from Casamel's again over the years.

We ordered Casamels through DoorDash last night for the first time and were extremely impressed with the quality of food. We ordered a large meat lovers pizza, cheesy breadsticks and mozzarella sticks. We may have found our go-to pizza place here in Cleveland!

Amazing pizza! First timer here! Good pizza is hard to come by. I will be back!! So yummy! I got the Deluxe pizza without the green peppers.

Ordered pizza and sides for the family through Uber eats that was to be picked up by me. Uber driver sees the large order on his/her screen and shows up and steals the food. Found out this is a thing that happens often at restaurants. That being said the Casamels manager would not replace the order because it wasn't their fault. I the customer was not at fault either. The food was stolen from them and not me. I nicely explained that they should want to please the customer and not alienate. We've always enjoyed their food. Just thought they could have stepped up and replaced the stolen food instead of sending me home empty handed. I wasn't about to double up and spend the money again. My son says never go back. What do you think??Just didn't seem fair at all.

Yesterday 9/4/24 about 3:30pm my grandma called regarding catering for my little cousins benefit for a kidney donation. Whoever answered the phone was extremely rude from the beginning. She politely asked for a manger to discuss catering (we're looking about 150 people so we were ready to spend money with the establishment). The person who answered the phone said "What do you need a manger for." My grandma then explained the benefit and catering size we are inquiring for. Then the employee said "you're going to need a lot of food," then proceeded to hang the phone up!! Not only are you missing out on a huge order to bring money to your business but now you also lost a full family that regularly orders from this establishment. Extremely disappointing!