Captain Tony's Pizza
Captain Tony's Pizza
6 Piece Small Famous Pizza
Small pepperoni and sausage pizza
Rather sorry excuse for deep dish... But still good
the front of the restaurant
a screenshot of a customer's profile
Chris M.
May 24, 2022
Tasty! We got I pepperoni pie, a meatball sub, 6 wingsPie was just fineMeatball sub really needs a stronger roll. Turned to mush like wonder-bread. Maybe we'll have it toasted next time, but it was tasty enough. Definite filler in recipe but thats super normal any more. Partner says wings were good and they did cook them well-doneWould give 4.5 - but an extra half star seems more reasonable that low-ballingAlso they do their own delivery!!!! HOORAY!
Read More
Jamie B.
Sep 4, 2018
Just moved to this area but have been in Little Italy and CLE Heights for the past 2 years, trying to find a decent close pizza spot. Live right next door so thought I'd finally try'em out. Service was fine and pizza was made fast, within 15 minutes! The pizza itself is just ok, glad I asked for well done, next time I may ask for extra well done. Nothing against them but just a typical 3 star pizza place, not bad but room to improve.
Read More
Regina X.
Feb 4, 2017
Super amazing joint great service best people the couple who runs this place is sooooo sweetWe got the honey mustard chicken wings, steak and cheese sub, BBQ chicken sub and chicken parm sub, everything was super delicious and definitely recommend!!!
Read More
AjJaree W.
Nov 25, 2020
I love this place, I was always going here growing up and decided to stop by here again once I saw it was still open. Nothing beats those spicy wings. YUM!
Read More
Tom S.
Mar 10, 2023
Consistently great pizza for at least 20 years. Staff is friendly too. Something special about the crust. Not sure what is, but it works for me.
Read More
Isaiah L.
Dec 5, 2022
Wanted something to get for me and my girl in a pinch before she got home from work, walked through Shaker Square and surprisingly this place was open went inside customer service was 10/10 had questions about what topping I can have they gave me the answer, the pizza was 9/10 the wings were 10/10 all around great for something in a pinch, prices were reasonable, and everything was all around great, Would definitely recommend
Read More
Matt F.
Jul 7, 2022
I would say this place is mediocre. The food arrived hot and they got the order correct, but everything was bland. The pizza had a decent amount of toppings on it, but just kind there. The penne was basically hot substance. It didn't have much of a taste and was lacking any sort of seasoning. Not much sauce and what was there was very underwhelming. We also got the hot sticks, which again, no flavor. I actually ate something else out of the fridge because I thought my taste buds were broken or something. We got a fair amount of food for the money, but nobody in the house was very satisfied. We wanted to try something new, but unfortunately won't be going back.
Read More
Tim J.
Jul 1, 2020
I love this place so much, the pepperonis are the perfect crisp, the crust is great, and the owner is so nice. Always a pleasure.
Read More
Logan J.
Jul 31, 2022
They said they were open online, but they weren't. This is your warning to not get too hungry and depend on Captain Tony's.
Read More
Emanuel A.
Jan 3, 2023
first thing really 0 stars I called to place a order. apparently it was the owner and he ask's what i'd like to order so i tell him and then he asked for my phone number so i gave it to him then he proceeded to say i dont want to take your order and hangs up the phone so i call back and ask why he cant take my order his response is "This is my restaurant i am the owner and i dont want to take your order" i Said nothing disrespectful or anything customer service needs improvement
Read More
