Brother's Pizza & Restaurant

Back again still fresh ingredients for a very good pizza....we have had the mushroom and pepperoni, also a mushroom and onion. Always good!I still have not tried the cheesesteak sub.

Short, sweet and to the point review... we just moved to town and wanted a simple pepperoni pizza. WARNING: CASH ONLY! We walked in, placed our order, ran to an ATM, and picked up a piping hot pepperoni pie 15 minutes later. Now, for something as simple as a pepperoni pie, you'd think there's not much to say, but honestly, this was one of the best pepperoni pizzas I've had outside of NYC. Nice thin crust. Perfect sauce: not too tangy, not too watery, just perfect. Just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. Cooked to perfection. It's really odd to get so exciting by such a simple food, but Brothers has the secret recipe and most of it is in the sauce. We'll be regulars, for sure.

I am trying to find the words to write for this review because we drove from Cleveland for an errand and decided to grab a pie to take back. It sat in the car til we got home so my opinion is a bit skewed. Reheated in the air fryer and it was good but I think next time, we'll eat there. My husband grew up in 44410 and vaguely remembers going there years ago.

Best pizza around!! It's my hometown favorite! Try the Sicilian pizza it's delicious! I never get disappointed here!

Always 5 stars for Brothers pizza in cortland. Friendly staff and always cooked to perfection. We always get carry out when we go but you also have to option to dine in. Top of our list when we want pizza,subs and basically everything on the menu.

The place has some really good food. Most of the staff a really nice. They love playing conservative conspiracy theories on tv. Also, it's 2024 going into a Trump presidency and they raised prices.

Really good pizza. Thinner crust, basic, but really good! First time ordering, if I'm in the area again, I'll get it again for sure!

The service was fine, we got Stromboli to go. It was pretty greasy, that I can get past. The actually taste was alright too, not the best, but not bad either. Just that I always order from the Brothers in champion and they were closed Sunday when we tried to order, so I figured it would be the same quality here. I was wrong, first the portion here was nothing compared to the other. When I get a medium at the other one, it takes me two meals at least to eat it all. This one was just a meal, if that. Secondly the taste it self, like I said it wasn't bad, but I would pass on It the next time if the champion location isn't open! I am not at all saying the food was bad, just not comparable in my own opinion!

Brothers has been around for a long time. Their pizza is very good, I love the crust, it's authentic Italian. The Sandwiches (Calzones and Stromboli) are the best in the area. The eating area very nice also. The place is packed around lunch time and usually busy the rest of the time too. My only qualm is that it's cash only which is not a problem. We should all be using cash before "they"get rid of it.I recommend this restaurant!

Delicious subs and pizza, very friendly and courteous staff. Always a favorite! Veggie pizza and tuna sub was delicious.