Angies New York Style Pizzeria

Was looking for a new pizza place. Read the reviews on here so decided to try it. And Yes, it was worth it. Smelled awesome so jumped in before pics, sorry. Big slices, generous toppings. Just a great pizza, best I've had in awhile. Really enjoyed it. Will Definitely be visiting again.

Very authentic. My favorite pie in Cleveland so far! I used to like Domino's but the one on Center st. Next to Yours Truly should be shut down.

I was hungry on a Thursday night, not wanting to leave my friends house to go get food. I came across this place on DoorDash and decided to try it out. They have a lot of choices to choose from. Appetizers, salads, calzones, pizza, entrees, and dessert. I ordered a small pizza with white sauce. It comes with your choice of 2 toppings. I'm a cheese lover so I chose extra cheese and ricotta. The crust. I love the crust. It's soft and doughy just the way I like it. It had an oh so garlicky sauce and yummy cheese. Finger licking good. The small pizza is 12 inches cut into 6 slices, pretty good size slices. My friend got the cavatelli pasta with meatballs. He let me try it and I thought it was pretty damn good. Nice size meatballs, soft pasta noodles, melted cheese on top. I'm not a big fan of red sauce but theirs is decent. If I get a red sauce, I prefer sweet, theirs isn't. He said he really liked it. Pastas come with a side salad and garlic bread. Big 2 slices of garlic bread. We shared the side salad. It came with pepperoni, olives, tomatoes, and banana peppers and Italian dressing. They have an app you can download for easy ordering and pickup. I will keep that in mind for next time. I want to try their big kahuna specialty pizza so I will for sure be back. Whoever says pineapple doesn't belong on pizza just doesn't get it, mmmk?

I did not know this place exists and I found it on YELP. My girlfriend and I enjoyed the pizza and that atmosphere of the staff was great. Definitely going back

Everything we have gotten here has been amazing. The people that work there are always friendly. The stuffed pizza is no joke. Take all my money, Angie's!

I want to like Angie's so much. I really do. We have ordered from them a lot lately and it's ok. It's never, and I mean never, consistent.Example...3 weeks or so ago, my husband ordered lasagna, and he raves about it so much that I picked it up the next night. Both times, it was a large piece of lasagna. Then we ordered it tonight, and it's half the size as it was 3 weeks ago (but not half the price). Garlic bread can be really good bread or sometimes it's literally sandwich bread from Giant Eagle. Baked ziti was incredible a few times, then tonight, it was just ok.I mean, we will probably order from them again but only get the things we know they do really well (husband and I have never had a bad calzone from there). But as far as ordering the more expensive dishes, we will look elsewhere. If the consistency issues are corrected, then I'd be willing to retry and order again. But we've noticed this for a while now, and MEntor is not lack8ng git Italian food.

So nice to find a new place that is actually good. Ordered a couple of subs and the appetizer. They are both huge..Very happy with everything. The Italian sub was awesome and I'm sure I'll finish it , tomorrow

Longtime family owned joint. Honestly a staple of mentor on the lake. Love their by the slice thing. Friendly people, great pizza. Been coming here for 20 years.

The New York style, thinner crust was exactly as it should have been. The sauce really ruined it for me though. The breading on the mozzarella moons (as well as the actual mozzarella) was tasteless. I also didn't order at a peak time, so I'm not sure why the pie was thrown together with sauce covering the entire crust in some parts or cheese only making it 2/3 of the way to the crust on other slices. Overall, if Little Cesar's had better quality cheese and better tasting sauce, there's a problem.

We ordered a pizza and wings on Sunday. The pizza was very good but the wings were Amazing. We ordered the Cajun Garlic Parm and they were the best wings we have had since moving here to the Cleveland area. We will be ordering wings very soon.