Alfees Pizza
Alfees Pizza
a half eaten plate of food
Burnt pizza the not so famous Alpha
"Buffalo" wings, except instead of buffalo sauce it was all grease and no sauce
Pizza
the front of the restaurant
the front of the restaurant
the entrance to the restaurant
the entrance to the restaurant
These are Supposed to be "Greek Dawgs" wheres the greek sauce‼ ALFEE's SUCKS
a variety of cheese and meats
chicken wings in a styrofoam container
R M.
Dec 19, 2023
Passing through on a roadtrip, last night on the road and we found the best road meal in over 3 weeks on the road. Long day on the road, wanted delivery. Aflees flyer in lobby, gave a call. Quick. easy ordering process with a real person. Order arrived at time specified, warm and ready to eat!!!Ordered cod dinner, fries, slaw. Nice filets, good serving of fries and slaw was tasty too.Pizza-topping as ordered, generously applied and the crust was amazing, chewy, textured, just amazing!!! Antipasto-crisp veggies, generous meats, cheese, peppers, chichi with an authentic Italian dressing. Order arrived with more than enough plates, napkins, condiments and utensils!Plenty of other things on the menu, now that I e tried the basics, I can imagine the specialties.........After an inedible, comedy of errors take out meal yesterday at a national chain (lazy, went closest, huge mistake) it was a reminder that our small businesses will still run circles around the big chains.
Read More
Val C.
Sep 1, 2023
Order sausage sub and combination. The combination had something very smoked on it and not the (capicola) I could not taste the zing that good capicola has. Very disappointing. Wings were good the teriyaki ones but my husband threw his buffalo wings in trash. We gave them a try with delivery and they were on time but looked forward to a sub tasting like Barbatos. Ugh won't do again.Where have all the good Italian sub/pizza shops gone too? Just saying. Oh , the bag came dripping with the teriyaki sauce and vegs were trashed. Don't think will give a second try since we spent so much money on these items. We had buyers regret.
Read More
Eric M.
Apr 1, 2023
Ordered food and was told that it would be delivered in 40 minutes, 1 hour and 5 minutes to arrive(4 miles from the Inn). Not only was he late, the sub was hot but all the food I ordered was cold and soggy(clams,fries and soft pretzel). Service was very poor. After 12 hours on the road not a very good ending to the day.
Read More
J V.
Apr 15, 2022
Arguably the best pizza in Erie. They offer some tables for dine in. We ate there at prime time on Friday evening and our order came out quickly. Generous cheese and toppings. They offer cans of pop and 2 liters, no fountain option. Highly recommend this place!
Read More
Ralph C.
Feb 18, 2025
We ordered 2 med pizzas, and 25 mild wings.We got the 2 pizza, one had a drop of sauce. The other saturated. The wings (mild)Were so hot, no one can eat therm. These were for kids 10 and under.We called and asked if there was a mistake.We were told that is the mild sauce.We asked for a replacement. They agreed. We asked for garlic parm,the guy on the phone said ,should be good for kids,Almost 2 hours later the kids were ready for bed, (we had given them a sandwich)The wings came and they were BBQ and undercooked. NEVER AGAIN!WORST FOOD AND SERVICE
Read More
Kevin S.
Feb 4, 2025
I heard about their pizza called the alpha Ater that was supposed to be certain price, but it was not. However, the pizza was really big so well with the $27 however the price is not as advertised. I just ordered a simple cheese and pep when it got here The bottom was burnt to a crisp as you will see to the picture that I am going to send not all of it was burnt, but I don't like any of it to be burnt. Completely honest. I called back. Let him know what was wrong with the pizza. He wanted to know if the cheese was burnt or the bottom and then let them know that the bottom was burnt and asked if he could just return my money. Come get this whole burnt pizza.. he informed me that it doesn't work like that buddy got to cussing at me and of course I called him a name back they're known for being disrespectful and ignorant, and they do not give money back on the poor quality of food that they're giving just a good heads up just regular people ordering a regular pizza shouldn't have to go through all that just to support a local business. they get five thumbs down and if you really wanna be cussed out, they're the people to call.!!!!!
Read More
Jaden D.
Oct 4, 2024
I use to get Alfee's all the time and never had a problem but the last 3 years they have been going down hill tremendously. I would not be surprised if they end up going out of business. I've never had a complaint about the wings until the last two times I've had them. I ordered buffalo wings and they just sent me some unseasoned wings sitting in a POOL of grease as if they used the container to scoop them out the fryers. The guy who took the call was a douche and that just me being nice.
Read More
Kristen Z.
May 18, 2024
Best Buffalo wings in Erie. That flavor. Buffalo. Pizza is pretty good too, but we get the Buffalo Wimgs every time.
Read More
Alexis F.
Jan 4, 2025
i just went to place a delivery order (for the first time in 5 years bc they suck but it's the only thing open) and they accused me of placing a order and not answering for the driver earlier today... umm i was def at work all day and if someone is using my address that's a whole other issue... ignorant AF. nasty food. terrible customer service. now i remember why i don't eat there. 0 stars.
Read More
Bonnie L.
May 30, 2024
It's awful pizza. Yelp averages two stars except for the very suspicious five star reviews.
Read More
