Old fashioned and the broken hatchet
Dirty smashed
menu
Chris, the bartender
people sitting at a bar
Entrance to Goodfellas Pizza, which is the front for Wiseguys speakeasy-style bar.
Wine
drink
Ashley's Blues cocktail.
a glass of whiskey on a wooden table
drink
Peerless Rye private pick!
drink
Peanut Butter Chocolate Martini
drink
a cocktail in a coupe glass
menu
two women sitting at a bar
drink
Pepperoni and Meatball!
Deliciously refreshing
drink
Steve M.
Nov 24, 2024
Here for B-Line passport. Love this pizza place! The slices are HUGE and tons of variety! Breadsticks as long as my arm!Upstairs is the bar:Definitely have to try the Peanut Butter Chocolate Martini!
Read MoreMackenzie K.
Feb 22, 2025
Rebecca is the best!!! we spent three hours there due to the vibes and her. great cocktails, funny humor, and great personality.
Read MoreDanielle J.
Sep 17, 2024
I am familiar with the wiseguy in Indianapolis, so wanted to check out this Covington location. Their menu had great seasonal options as well as bartender recommendations, they were able to elevate their bourbon smash with honey, lemon, they offered blueberry as they were out of blackberry. It was a busy Saturday night great seating but a little more loud due to college football games, but overall still a relaxed vibe. Also highly recommend trying their limited peanut butter tequila! Very unique.
Read MoreDanny A.
May 10, 2024
I absolutely loved this upstairs lounge! While the space isn't very big there is a nice size bar that can seat about 8 and some surrounding leather couches and tables to hang out. The place has a lot of dark woods and earth tones making it warm and inviting. Our bartender, Dan, was absolutely FANTASTIC. Aside from making some kick butt drinks he was super friendly and knowledgeable. As the night progressed and it slowed down a bit he was able to spend some time chatting with us and entertain us. 100% the reason why I sit at the bar. Loved everything about this place. Down below is a Wiseguys Pizza so grab a slice and make your way upstairs for a few beverages.
Read MoreWendy K.
Feb 4, 2024
It's a unique situation with an amazing pizza joint below and a bar on top. We met friends, got drinks and enjoyed a slice of pie. Drinks were ok. The pizza is probably some of the best in this area. We will definitely return for the pizza,
Read MoreNanette B.
Aug 24, 2024
Had a magical late summer evening at Wiseguy Lounge with friends. Expert bartender Chris kept the amazing cocktails flowing and we enjoyed them on the cool and comfortable upstairs patio with a great pizza from Goodfellas. Love the mix of top notch drinks paired with always satisfying pizza.
Read MoreTyanna M.
Sep 6, 2024
We stopped here to have a couple cocktails. We stopped because we absolutely love the Wiseguy Lounge in Indianapolis, we stop there often. So in comparing the two there is really no comparison. The bartender here had no charisma and also seemed like she didn't really care if we were there or not. One of the things we really enjoy about ordering cocktails in the Indy location is the flare the cocktails are served with and the extremely friendly outgoing bartenders there. I gave it two stars because the one cocktail we had each were ok. We will not be stopping here again as there are many other options in this neighborhood.
Read MoreMargarite B.
May 25, 2024
Loved it! They have a peanut butter tequila that's so delicious- iykyk!!- Chris C. was our bartender, and he was awesome! He created a drink on the menu called "Black Incantation" and it was so delicious. If you get the chance to try it before they change over to their summer menu, please do! But I'm sure whatever new creation he conjures for the summer menu will be just as good!
Read MoreGlenn W.
Oct 1, 2024
Holy shit! Peanut butter tequila! I don't mean peanut butter flavored tequila. I mean, they took peanut butter and added tequila to it until, when mixed, it was thin enough to drink. I don't know how I made it back to my hotel room. Wow. Also, staff was cool and it's a neat space. But damn. Peanut butter tequila.
Read MorePatrick D.
Dec 15, 2024
Riley makes the best manhattan in the city with great service and fantastic personality
Read More