Two Cities Pizza Company

Love that you can choose between Chicago and NY Style. Both are really good and come quickly. Salads are fantastic and the place is just a good vibe that is remarkable to view (an old fire station maybe?)The wait is long but worth it!

Dinner Saturday night Our group got several pizzas, They loved them.Now I just had a salad.House plus grilled chicken.My salad was ok.Chicken was over seasoned.Good service.Busy restaurant.

Always great pizza (and the best martinis in Mason) brings us back here again and again. We love the food, and the service is always stellar.Probably the best managed pizza joint I've found. You'll see everyone pitch in to make it a great place for the customers. Love it!

The pizza here is scrumptious. The pizza is soft and the sauce is mouthwateringly good and the cheese is amazing. The pizza is made with love and it shows. It's a special flavorful experience. This is pizza made to the highest grade and would highly recommend if you like good pizza. Also got the bone in wings which were delicious. They were all evenly sauced. They are generous with the sauce. The ambiance is friendly, warm, and inviting. This is one of my favorite pizza spots and will leave you feeling full and happy.

First let's start with planning to wait. We called in to get on the list at 5 pm on a Saturday. I understand Saturday is a busy night so knew there would be a wait. Was advised it's a hour and a half to hour and forty five minute wait. Our wait ended up being just over 2 hours. Upon sitting down we were greeted by our server Allyssa. She was so friendly and knowledgeable. Extremely polite also. She was very attentive and cannot say enough at what a great job she did. She made then evening enjoyable. She didn't hover nor ignore. She just gave us great service. The place has a cool atmosphere and vibe. Don't forget to check out the subway bathroom if you visit. Will say the noise level is above average. Don't be surprised if it's a bit loud. We started with a couple appetizers. The bootleg bread and Mac and cheese balls. We also had a couple side salads. The Waldorf and the Melting Pot. Since there were 4 of us we all got our own personal pizza. 2 New York style and 2 Chicago style. The New York was thin and crispy as one would expect. Toppings were just ok. Unfortunately nothing to brag on. Was still a tasty pizza for what I had. The Chicago style looked kind of sloppy so be prepared. Unfortunately my wife didn't enjoy her pizza at all. Just seemed bland. The other 3 of us did enjoy ours. As anyplace you go to it's a matter of taste.

We were coming home from our Hocking Hills trip. My Mr and I were craving pizza. I saw Two cities Pizza on google and read more reviews on Yelp. What sold me was the building. I love restaurants in historical building plus they were voted best pizza a couple years back. We definitely had to check them out. We walked in and I couldn't stop taking pictures. The owner happened to be in the front and greeted us. He gave us a brief history and we walked around a bit. This used to be the mayors office back in the day. When you walk in, it has an outdoor city feel. I love the decor. It's very nostalgic. And wait until you go to the bathroom! It's a subway. I was told this was voted best restaurant bathroom. So they serve New York and Chicago style pizzas. They have specialty , build your own or cauliflower crust & dairy free cheese for dietary restrictions. If you're not feeling pizza , they do serve appetizers, wings, calzones, salads and desserts. We ordered:Drinks:-Cabernet Trim-Ale of two cities Appetizer:-Legendary Parmesan FriesLunch:-Medium Classic Margherita Add pepperoniWe got the Parmesan Garlic Fries as an appetizer and really loved it! It didn't need the ranch dressing but enhanced it. The pizza was amazing! They are on my top 5 list in the Cincy area. The crust tasted really good dipped in the garlic butter sauce. Fresh ingredients on the pizza. Love the robust tomato sauce. Paired well with my wine.We were not expecting this but the owner gave us a complimentary dessert. Funnel cake doughnuts sprinkled in powdered sugar. What a nice surprised and very grateful! The doughnuts were fresh and still warm in the middle. It definitely hit the spot.What an awesome experience! I can't wait to come back and bring my friends. They are going to love it here!

On the way home from Hocking Hills, my lady and I were wanting pizza, and my lady found this spot on a Google search. Glad she found it because it was excellent and not just for the pizza. The service was awesome, the place has a very unique and classic vibe, and we really enjoyed everything.We stopped in on Sunday a little after 11am. You can tell this building was an old municipal building and they kept pretty much all the old decor. We were immediately greeted by the owner/operator who was very friendly and inviting. He invited us to look all around the place too. He told us that, not only were they voted best pizza in Cincinnati two years, they were also voted best restroom. Seriously, you'll have to check it out, because it looks like a NY subway station complete with the sounds. Our server, Alyssa, was GREAT. Their menu features lots of appetizer options as well as calzones, salads, and both NY and Chicago style pizza. Their libations menu is nice too with a great beer and wine list as well as specialty cocktails. They even have an exclusive pale ale made by Sonder Brewing. Of course, I ordered it, and it was very tasty. My lady ordered a Cabernet for herself. We started with the legendary parmesan fries, which were some of the best fries we'd had in a while, made even better by the house made ranch that came with them. From there, we ordered a medium NY style margherita pizza, half with pepperoni added because they suggested it in the menu. Was that good too? Absolutely! My lady and I couldn't stop raving about it. After we were done, we received an unexpected surprise, in the form of some complimentary "first timer" mini donuts. They made the perfect sweet tooth finish to our meal for sure. A little crunchy on the outside, soft and warm on the inside, topped with powdered sugar.We will definitely be coming back here again because everything was so good. I have a feeling we'll be bringing some friends along next time too. Knowing me, being a big fan of wings, I'll have to try theirs soon. I cam see why this spot wins awards.

This place is so cute! I am a transplant from NY and man! This place made me feel at home! It was spacious and loud, and the food was really good. I had a screaming two year-old with us and no one really batted an eye and the waitress was amazingly patient. I have the Caesar salad, which was perfect: the right amount of cheese and dressing. My daughter started eating the Greek salad, but once her wings came, she abandoned ship because the wings were so good. She had the buffalo flavor. I was happy to find out you could split a medium with two different flavors so I had.Thyme square and classicMargarita. I got the cauliflower crust and you couldn't even sell. It was a cauliflower crust ordered. We also ordered the mozzarella sticks from the kids meal and it was really nice portion for kids meal and they were really well breaded. My favorite part of course was the bathroom area which had a subway theme along with the conductor recording and the map and a sliding subway door. Inside there was graffiti and subway handles that were perfectly reminiscent of New York City subways. I admit I was surprised at the bill, but I guess I'm really shouldn't be because the price tag was also reminiscent of New York. Can't wait to come back!

This is a big restaurant that offers carry out and dine in. The restaurant decor was very fun. I loved having the deep dish and thin crust pizza. We tried their wings with sweet chili sauce, I definitely look forward to having their wings again. The pizza I got was a deep dish with potatoes and bacon. Very unique pizza option with the ability to create your own. Their cocktails were on the sweeter side likely from the syrups but had good flavor.

Everything about this place was amazing. We tried unique food, had the best wings we've ever had, delicious beer and topped it off with some yummy ice cream. Can't wait to visit again.