Trophy Pizza - Evendale

Great food and great service. I've been in twice for the last two weeks and both times I left happy. Not just the pizza alone, I had a Caesar salad and garlic knots. This is a don't miss restaurant.

I was craving some pizza and my mom suggested going to Trophy. I didn't know there was a pizza place like this so close to home and where I work! I would definitely recommend dining in to get some fresh, crispy, thin crust pizza slices. They have so many different options to choose from. I love their peppery pig pizza with some hot honey drizzled on top! The workers there are so nice and very quick to get your pizza to you. Trophy is now one of my top picks for pizza and I'll definitely be coming in more for lunch!!

The pizza was good! With so many other options, not sure I would return for the price. We have heavy hitters in Cincy and Trophy is by far the most expensive.

Love this place. Just discovered it a couple of months ago. Delicious pizza & they make their own ranch dressing. The staff is friendly & patient. We get a pie every week or two now. You can tell it is chef owned & driven.

We ordered pizza from here via uber eats pick up today and it was really good! Still hot, crispy crust, and fresh after a drive home. We ordered the loophole pizza. It was quite tasty!y husband felt it could use a bit more ranch while I would have preferred a few more jalapeños. Other than that, flavor was delicious! We will definitely order from here again!

This pizza is ok. We ordered online for delivery and it arrived within the specified time and was hot and fresh. And I liked that the box was sealed with tape to prevent tampering. It's an expensive pizza because it is so huge! One pizza will easily feed 4 adults. We ordered a Pepperoni Pizza with Pineapple on half. I could only eat one piece. My grandson barely made it through one piece and my husband had two slices. We warmed it up in the oven today - so it wouldn't go to waste. My husband and grandson both had one more slice and there's still two more in the fridge. None of us cared for how overly chewy the crust is on this pizza. Really, really chewy. Is it always this chewy and kind of burnt on the bottom? Was the dough overworked in the mixer or is it just how the crust is on this pizza? No clue but we didn't like it. The sauce and toppings were ok. Definitely nothing to rave about but not bad pizza. Maybe if I'm ordering for a group of people I might give them another try.

Finally visited Trophy Pizza for their rumored amazing New York slice. They delivered, ten fold!! As a native New Yorker, I can tell you this is spot on for New York style pizza. We got two pepperoni slices and a slice of their Yes Way to share. HOT & FRESH! Service was great, people behind the counter were very friendly. Location is a bit out of the way but certainly more accessible than flying to NY. Highly recommend!

I've been eager to try this place for a while to see if they really make a good New York-style pizza, and I wasn't disappointed. It's about as authentic as you can get in Cincinnati. The pizza features big slices on a thin crust, served hot and crunchy straight from the oven. Both the pepperoni and the classic cheese were fantastic.The only downside was that the restaurant was a bit warm for dining in, but the friendliness of the staff more than made up for it. Overall, it's definitely worth a visit for a taste of New York right here in Cincinnati.

The pizza is closer to New York style pizza , then any other I've tried in the Midwest. The service was friendly. The decor is strictly pizza shop. If you like pizza, and especially, if you miss East Coast pizza, give it a try. I'll be back soon.

Best Pizza in Cincinnati hands-down. Perfectly cooked crust and cheese there Crisp is unmatched.