Pizza not prepared well
Fish & Chips and BLT
a variety of neon signs
Front of the menu as of 10/12/24.
Outside taken from the front door of the sign.
Beautiful place to eat
Back of the menu as of 10/12/24
The booths are church pews
14 inch ham, bacon, banana pepper pizza from Tollhouse Tavern
people sitting at the bar
people sitting at the bar
the menu and prices
the front of the house
a pizza with olives and peppers
nachos, food
poultry, food, chicken, chicken wings, bbq wings, bbq chicken, fried chicken wings, fried chicken, chicken wings and fried chicken
chicken wings, poultry, chicken, bbq wings, bbq chicken, food, fried chicken wings, fried chicken, chicken wings and fried chicken
Me n my fiance
Michelle B.
Oct 12, 2024
We have been here a few times and the food is always good and so is the service. I got the Fish & Chips and my husband got a BLT. The cole slaw and fries were very good. The fish was thinner than I expected but had very good flavor. All of the sauces are made in house and the cocktail sauce is amazing. The best I have ever had. We will definitely be back.
Read More
Jeff C.
Jun 14, 2023
How can an establishment go from making one of the best pizza you've had to one not even close? Not busy and was very specific, well done, not a lot of cheese, some sauce. Soft ,greasy ,cheesy barely cooked. And $4 for a 16 oz draft ? Not open Sundays and Mondays. Unfortunately you can't stay open with only a few employees that care. Pay attention to what your customers ask for. It's not that hard when there are only 6 people in the building. Miss the good pizzas from years ago. Miggt get one out of ten. And $11 for a small 2 topping.pizza is a joke.
Read More
April C.
Jul 7, 2022
The friend cauliflower was good. I'll probably try something different next time. The fish was served plain. If I get it again, I'll ask for cheese. I did add a little thousand island dressing and tarter sauce for zing. Very delicious. My fiance ordered the Ruben. When I asked him how he liked it, he said "it's not bad but they are charging $12 for an $8 sandwich." I put $1 in the jute box to play "brown eyed girl." My fiance said it was too loud so I did not use the rest of my purchase. Hopefully the next person can pick a song.Pleasant waitress. 5 stars for the staff and the presentation of the establishment.
Read More
Doug R.
Jun 29, 2022
Toll House Tavern is almost my hometown go to for great sandwiches, soups and after football games on a Friday night memories. Great food & great setting. Just not my hometown!
Read More
Mark S.
Feb 9, 2023
Premade pizza crusts. Everything is frozen and deep fried. Nothing seemed to be homemade.
Read More
Ashley O.
May 27, 2021
This place was okay. Servers were quick and got us our beers and food fast. Pizza was just okay. The crust was bland, tomato sauce tasted like it was from a can. Ham and bacon toppings were generous. I did like the stained glass windows and neon lights. Made for a colorful atmosphere in a dark restaurant.
Read More
J C.
Nov 15, 2019
Well, they USED to have really good pizza....NOT ANYMORE!! If you want scant canned sauce and soggy, greasy crust under 4 pounds of cheese - come here! We have asked numerous times for a lite amount cheese thinking that the doofus in the back could put on a normal amount of cheese, but it still comes out just over the top with the cheese. This place has got to be having a huge food cost because of the dingbats making this pizza. What do they do if someone actually asks for extra cheese? Give them a bag of it on the side? Its entirely too much and because of that and trying to give them chance after chance, I will never go back!!I do want to say that the servers are very nice! This critique is souly on the food...
Read More
Kim B.
Jul 30, 2022
Came here on a Saturday night, dinner time, waited one hour and 45 minutes for our dinner to come, and it wasn't even busy, you should close the restaurant when your cooks walked out again, or at least let the customers know that it could be a two hour wait because there's only one cook! Never again!
Read More
Frank C.
Apr 5, 2022
It's been several years since I'd visited as I live 500 miles away. This used to be regular spot 20 years ago or so. It's definitely not what it used to be. The best part of the experience was the conversation with the 2 customers.
Read More
Brian H.
Dec 21, 2023
love it! Great wait staff! The bacon cheese fries are great... dip them in their special ranch dip and they're amazing! Tollhouse is our regular Friday dinner!
Read More