This is the Buckeye Cheesecake Cupcake, the Oreo Cheesecake Cupcake, the Buckeye and the Brownie Cheesecake Cupcake.
a hand holding a piece of cake
a variety of iced drinks
a variety of coffee cups and mugs
a person holding a cookie
a display of cakes and pastries
outside
Front door
Mini Cheesecake Cupcake Oreo, Reeses cups, vanilla and cookies and cream if not mistaken.
Fall latte list
outside
food
Bakery
Reese's cheesecake
Gingerbread cheesecake
Cake batter macaron
food
Coffee flight flavors of the month
outside
Erini N.
Feb 14, 2025
Tried tiramisu and the caramel macchiato cheesecake and YUM.. would definitely order this again. Did not visit in person but plan on it soon
Read MoreJohn S.
Aug 25, 2024
Forgot to take a picture of my scone but that was easily my favorite thing. The s'mores latte was fantastic and I was happy to share the 4 pack with some friends. The inside of the place was cute but a little small. There is no longer indoor seating and only outdoor. Service was great though and both employees were super nice!
Read MoreConnie H.
Apr 19, 2024
Picked up a few cheesecakes for a colleagues birthday and they were a big hit! Everyone loved the variety. The shop is adorable. Parking can be hard at times. Employees were cheerful and greeted me when I walked in.
Read MorePavel V.
Jul 13, 2024
When I saw a cheesecake truck I did not expect it to be this good. The employees in the truck seemed a little distracted inside but one apologized and was very nice. The cheesecakes looked very nice aesthetically, like gourmet cupcakes, but better. The whipped cream was amazing, I could eat a whole tub. And the cheesecakes were even better. I got one strawberry and one raspberry and couldn't get enough of both. If this place was nearby I would definitely cater them.
Read MoreDonnie M.
Jan 28, 2024
I have a friend that loves cheesecake so my wife and I stopped here to get them a birthday treat. They absolutely loved the cheesecakes and couldn't wait to visit the place themselves.We grabbed a couple iced coffees while we were which were delicious. Not too sweet which was surprising considering they were based off cheesecake flavors.It's a small place but they have a fine-in area a couple doors down.
Read MoreAnna P.
Jul 22, 2024
Came on my birthday - I was so excited!I got 3 cheese/cupcakes - 1 classic, 2 of the seasonal/ rotating flavors.The classic was a curdled, sour old cheesecake that was hard on top as it had obviously been there for a long time. One of the seasonal cheesecakes had a hair on it. They were wearing hairnets - it happens, tho.I left this same review on Google, and now it's mysteriously gone... Long story short, I ate 1 of the 3 cheesecakes - it was good. Won't return simply because I was served a sour, old cheesecake.Ps - the interior is adorable. Everything is pink and cutesy
Read MoreGemma S.
Aug 4, 2023
A fun little bakery that I'm glad I got to check out over in Madisonville! To start off, in general, I am typically not the biggest fan of cheesecake. I usually like the crust of the cake more than the actual cheesecake itself. HOWEVER, The Cheesecakery's bite-sized cheesecake cupcakes were perfect for me for this reason; they weren't too big and overwhelmingly rich, but still sweet and really good!It is a little confusing as there are two stores (a cafe and a bakery), but I ended up finding the bakery one just fine. I believe there is only street parking, as that is where I parked myself. Upon entry, the space is small, but very cute. There is a lot of color on the inside, including plenty of information about catering if you are interested. They offer a variety of different cheesecake cupcakes to pick from, including seasonal flavors, as well as cookies, macaroons, and more. Everything is clearly on display, and you can ask questions if you're interested in what any of the flavors specifically taste like. I decided to try the oreo, the reese's, and the buckeye cheesecake. As I mentioned, I do like cheesecake crust, and the oreo crust was amazing. I would've eaten just that if I could've, it was that good. The oreo cheesecake was definitely my favorite overall, but all were excellent. The two people working at the bakery were incredibly kind when I went in. They informed me that The Cheesecakery is actually celebrating its fourth year in business as of this week! They were both very attentive, and I'm glad I got the chance to speak with them. I would recommend checking this place out if you're a fan of cheesecake, or have a sweet tooth in general.
Read MoreMeg E.
Jan 23, 2023
I heard about this delightful dessert place on Instagram and was so happy to check it out next time I was in Ohio. I stopped for coffee first. On one corner is the coffee shop, the corner across the street has more dessert. The staff was sweet and explained the seasonal flavors. I ended up getting a hot snickerdoodle latte. Immediate deliciousness on the slightly higher boujee coffee side but worth it, adorned with an adorable thick red heart sticker to keep the drink hole covered (and beverage hot) when not sipping. Next I headed down to get additional desserts. The little Debbie Christmas tree cake cheesecakes got me in, I was pleasantly surprised to see they also came in cake pop form! I got a variety of cheesecakes, a few pops, and a few macarons. Prices were very reasonable. Upon getting home, I loved the little Debbie pops. In fact, my brother said it was one of the best things he has ever eaten and he teared up during the last bite, haha. My mom said the macaron, which are also a bit larger than a traditional macaron (zero complaints about that!) was one of the best she's ever had, and these are her favorite dessert. I agree with both sentiments! The cheesecake, what they are obviously known for, was not anyone's favorite. The paper stuck to the cheesecake was slightly disintegrated into the dessert, so we lost about 1/3 of each, bummer. The flavor of each was okay. The Oreo cake pops, and we love all things Oreo, wasn't fantastic. The middle tasted of pure cream cheese, with an odd texture I was not impressed with. Overall these shops are great, as is the flavor of most desserts (well priced!) and boujee coffees. The staff has been kind during my visits, too. I look forward to returning once more and giving the cheesecakes another try, as well as ordering a coffee flight from one of the rotating menus. This is a perfect spot for a cutesy day out, too!
Read MoreLydia T.
Sep 29, 2024
The best cheesecake in the city of Cincinnati. I also always get a seasonal coffee while I'm there. The menu is always so fun and it is such a cute space.
Read MoreWilliam W.
Feb 22, 2025
The cheese cake is amazing! The staff is very professional and friendly and will make helpful suggestions.
Read More