The Brooklyn Pizza

I was quite pleased with the pizza here. I'm originally from New Jersey, so I know great pizza and honestly, when I came here with a business associate, I was not expecting the pizza to be as good as it was. I must say that I was pleasantly surprised. The place was nothing fancy in twems of ambiance, but it was pleasant enough and really, there is nothing fancy about pizza. The service was also friendly and professional. All in all, I would definitely recommend here.

Thankful to have a good pizza spot on the east end of Seymour. Very convenient for takeout, but have also eaten inside too. There is a 21+ only side with a bar and also a family room, which is where you place your order at the counter. Paper plates and silverware make for a casual dining experience and easy cleanup. Owner and staff is very nice & personable. They also have a spot for outdoor music. Bonus perks: get their punch card rewards to earn a free pizza, and also sign up for their texts to get deals :)

Great place located in a neighborhood mixed with businesses and homes. I had baked spaghetti, which I had never had before. It had a layer of baked cheese on top. I ate it all, even though I was full. Their garlic bread sticks are fantastic. They're brushed with butter and baked with garlic salt. I had a mixed green salad, which was one of the freshest salads I've had. Our friends had pizza, and barbecue chicken wings.If you're ever in Seymour, Indiana, this is a great place to visit. If you're cruising i-65, it's worth your time to get off the interstate and treat yourself.

ABSOLUTELY PERFECT PIZZA! Not too thick and not too thin, and we love the cornmeal on the crust. The cheese is really flavorful and the sweet sauce is so good! Also super nice staff! We will definitely be back!

Guys seriously... Don't walk, RUN to Brooklyn! It is an absolute GEM! The pizza is amazing, the atmosphere is unbeatable. Every time we are in the area we come at least once. The "standard" flavors are always a smash (veggie and meatza always hit the spot) and the unusual ones are even better (funky chicken and the one with chorizo) are some of the best pizzas I've ever had.

Absolutely amazing food and beer. We tried the spicy mutha clucka and it did not disappoint. We will definitely be back next time we're in town. Everyone was also so friendly and wonderful.

Amazing food and great service and by far the friendliest people you will ever meet. They can fix any kind of pizza you want if you haven't tried them please do.

I love this place EXCEPT for the canned mushrooms. You can ask for fresh mushrooms, but why bother because half the time either the server/bartender doesn't hear you or the kitchen screws it up. I wish they would just get rid of the canned mushrooms and raise prices. Other than that, this place is one of my favorites in the area, including Madison and Scottsburg. Be sure and double check the hours. Like any small business, the hours change frequently. Great pizza (except those mushrooms) and great beer! Live music often.

Driving through Indiana looking for some pizza for dinner. Found this one and decided to give it a try. It's about 4 miles off the interstate but the food was worth it. Pizza came out great and hot. The staff were friendly and fast.

Malone is a great owner, promoter and chef. The beer, wings and music were great! A must stop if in Seymour...