Birthday cake
Iced brownie of my dreams!!
The Best!
a sign hanging from the side of a building
a cookie with oreo cookies on top
a box of cupcakes with frosting and sprinkles
Cookie with cream and chocolate chips
food
Hand for scale. These are huge.
Plain Jane Brownie
food
interior
outside
outside
(Clockwise, Top left) oatmeal chocolate chunk, lemon, blueberry, oatmeal cream, pie, & chocolate chip bomb
Cinnamon Toast Crunch s'mores cookie
food
food
Oatmeal crème pie
Birthday cake
Oatmeal Cookie Pie
Cookie pie, stuffed Nutella cookie and Oreo cookie
Neapolitan cake
Raneka D.
Jan 12, 2025
Gourmet cookies! What an experience...I tried the chocolate chip cookies for my 1st visit and they did not disappoint. The cookies are a nice size and very moist. There were other flavors as well they looked delicious. I would definitely suggest this spot for great desserts if you are ever in the area.
Read MoreAndrea T.
Oct 21, 2023
We stopped at Sugar after having dinner in Over The Rhine. The walk up window was wonderful. You can grab a sweet treat and continue to stroll. You could see perfectly what they offered through the window and service was quick. Among other items you could get a ice cream sandwich made with Jeni's ice cream.You could tell it is a popular dessert spot based on the line. We ordered an oatmeal crème pie and M&M cookie. The cookies were enormous. One cookie was enough for two people. If you want to stroll around with a sweet treat this is the place for you.
Read MoreEric G.
Jun 8, 2024
We got there right as they unlocked the door and the employee working was very nice and welcoming!You order at a little walkup window and you can see the cookies and other baked goods through the window. We got the chocolate chip bomb cookie and it is honestly one of the best cookies I've ever had in my life and my boyfriend agrees with that sentiment. Great location near a lot of restaurants if you want a little sweet treat after you're done eating.
Read MoreAaron M.
Dec 22, 2024
Amazing! The service was exceptional. I would recommend Sugar to everyone and will return soon
Read MoreShantell P.
Sep 10, 2022
Cannot say enough good things about this place! The perfect stop for those who need something sweet after a meal in OTR. We have had the Brookie before and it was amazing, but there are so many interesting options! This time around, we got the Oatmeal Cookie Pie, and it surprised us with how amazing it was. It was the perfect amount of sweet with not being overpowering.
Read MoreSheryar K.
Sep 10, 2022
If you want a quick on the go dessert after your dinner in OTR. This little hole-in-the-wall (Literally it's a window on a building) is absolutely perfect a little sweet treat for us whenever we go out in OTR. This time around we got a oatmeal cookie pie and it was amazing, not too sweet and perfect ratio of cream and cookie. we got one to share with 2 people and it was more than enough!A regular cookie is $3 a premium i think is $7 but they're huge and so soft!
Read MoreDonnie M.
Sep 2, 2023
This little walk up window is the perfect place to stop for a quick sweet treat. They serve Jenni's ice cream and all sorts of baked goods. My wife and I grabbed a couple cookies for our first time there and they did not disappoint. These cookies are what Dirty Dough advertises but don't actually deliver on. The brookie was a chocolate chip cookie with a full brownie stuffed inside and it was delicious.
Read MoreErika G.
Jun 19, 2024
I've never not had something I've loved from Sugar their cookies are delicious and it's even nice to be able to pick up some Jeni's ice cream if the mood suits. My new favorite after getting some local delivery to our office is the S'mores Cake!
Read MoreRebecca M.
Mar 30, 2023
A walk up window full of treats? Say less. Love this convenient stop in the heart of OTR with extended hours! If you're not an ice cream fan, dessert options are limited in this area. Sugar has swooped in and solved a problem for those of us who love to carb up on sugary half pound cookies, brownies, cookie sandwiches and more! The half pound chocolate chip cookie was exciting to purchase but too overwhelming... way too much chocolate chips. BUT the walnut brownie and oatmeal sandwich cookie makes up for it! Would absolutely grab a brownie from Sugar anytime!
Read MoreOneya O.
Jul 31, 2022
Look no further for some of the best sweet treats on Cincinnati! Sugar made me a towering Neapolitan cake for my PhD graduation party that all the guests raved over. Anytime I'm in OTR on the weekend I stop by for inventive cookies that make you say "I need that!" My favorites are any version of their s'mores cookie and the chocolate biscoff.
Read More