a box of food
The pecan pie. Yes please!
bakery and orchard
Steve S.
May 10, 2020
Had a pie from this Bakery today that a friend gave me. The review is based only on that pie.We had the pecan pie. Ok, not made the way my grandma would make it but it was pretty good. I would do this pie again when/if I get the chance. It gets a recommend from me. Just FYI, granny would have had a bit more filling and baked it a bit longer so the crust would be golden brown.
Read More
Samantha L.
Oct 3, 2022
While visiting family in Columbus, we went apple picking and produce shopping at Stevens Bakery & Orchard. In addition to the apples we picked, we bought a zucchini, broccoli, and several blueberry and peach half pies. Everything was reasonably priced. We liked how the pies had the right amount of sweetness!
Read More
Nijole T.
Feb 18, 2014
I got a huge pecan pie from Stevens Bakery & Orchard, I think it was 6 or $8.99.I purchased it at Weiland's Market in Columbus, the pie being the best thing that store has to offer.it was fresh, tasty and full of pecans, though way too much of the cornstarchy middle, which I dislike.It was fine, but i don't think I would go out of my way to try one of their pie's again.
Read More
Sara C.
Feb 9, 2014
I haven't been to the actual bakery and orchard, but one of my friends brought their peanut butter pie to a dinner this weekend and OMG. There were four of us at the party and by the end of the evening there was only one slice of pie left.I've seen their pies for sale at Mosleys and Weilands in Columbus, and according to their website they also can be bought at both of the Hills Markets. They're a little pricier than your average grocery pie, but oh so delicious. I'll be on the lookout for the chocolate pie next time I need to bring a dessert to a party!
Read More
David F.
Sep 8, 2017
Our family had a great time last weekend picking apples and grabbing a few out things from their store. Our kids got a kick out of the wagon ride too! The blackberry preserves and apple pie were both great.The orchard is a little bit of a drive but definitely worth it. If you use GPS, ours tried to have us enter from Coffin Station Road so make sure you are heading to Thackery Rd and they have a sign at their driveway.
Read More
Pat W.
Aug 14, 2017
We have always loved your pies. We had not had one for several months, and I bought an apple one yesterday in Worthington area at Hill's Market. My husband and I were surprised with the changes. It was tart, and apples were in little chunks, and way too much of the gel-like filling. Crust is still great, but wouldn't spend the 17$ again if this is indicative of the "newer" recipe.
Read More
Jan M.
Jan 26, 2011
Off the beaten path, Steven's is a great place to visit when you are in the mood for apples or baked goods. The pies are wonderful, but the pumpkin rolls are some of the best I have enjoyed!
Read More
Lee Ann C.
Jul 28, 2023
Just had a piece of chocolate chip pie from Stevens Bakery. It was very tasty but I found a hair in it after eating over 1/2 of the piece. I know that accidents can happen but this is a long hair so someone did not wear a hair net while preparing this our. It made almost made me throw up! Beware of hair if you get a pie from Stevens! It was purchased at Hills Market.
Read More