Petey's Pizza & Carry Out

Has been the best pizza in the area for a long time!! #tacopizza is the best ! I have never had bad food from here!

Pizza is good. Service is great. Thin or thick crust. 14 different toppings to choose from. A few sandwiches and bread stix available. They are good and a small privately owned place... So on a busy night you may have to wait a little longer than you wanted. But the time they tell you is right on or a slight ponder estimate.... Been eating here for decades.

We order a pizza about once a week, and it's always very good. Petey has the best pizza in the Greenville-Arcanum area. They normally have an order ready in 15-20 minutes from the time the order is placed. Delivery is available locally.

We have ordered lots of pizzas from here over the years. Always good pizza and great attitudes.

I have never had anything bad here and I have been eating here since I was a kid! Subs are always great and special orders are never a problem. Pizza is the best in the area.

I love Peteys! It's the best pizza I have had in Ohio. The sauce is great and the toppings are just right! Delicious and affordable. Nice folks working there too!

This place has been around since I was a kid. Pretty good for small town pizza. Give it a whirl if you're in town.

I have had peteys before and it was great However, tonight when I got there to pick up my order they gave me my pizza without my order of wings ready then found out that they completely forgot to put my wings in. After they told me it would be 5 mins i wait about -10-12 and they only had half my order ready and my pizza was half cold already. I decided to get my money back, it was absolutely terrible and seemed to be filled with young teenagers who didn't care about customer service or doing their job. I'm very disappointed and most likely won't be going back and would not recommend to anyone.

Best pizza I've ever eaten in my life especially with ranch I don't know what it is about small local business that don't look like they can even pass a health inspection but there food is so good

Just discovered this place! The pizza is really good! Had the thin crust. The service was efficient and polite. There are a few tables but this is a carryout place. My husband eats pizza at least 3 times a week. This is my favorite!