Pastizza

If you like NY style pizza, this is the best slice in the area. Maybe even in the whole city.Crust is great with no aftertaste (unlike the place across from Kenwood). Order "well done" if you like it crisp. Sauce has good tang to it. We are a pretty toppings-forward family, but we usually just get cheese here because it's so good. Pro tip: Their online ordering is pretty bootleg. If you want something like "well done" or "double cut", just put in your order on the site and then call them. You'll get someone helpful that can add that request, not a host stand that has to put you on hold.Super nice people there. Support local businesses.

The food here is high quality. I understand that the owners learned to make Pizza in NYC. Unfortunately, they are also pricing in NYC prices. $26 for a large pizza is too much, considering other shops in the area (like Italianette) will offer twice as much Pizza for the same price, delivered. Calzones are $14.Also, they took over a site that was a pet food bakery. It's carry out only, so it's not like rent is a big cost driver. It's a competitive area, with Ali's, Dominos, A Tavola (voted #1 in Cincinnati) Hoppin Vines, Ferrari's all offering pizza for less. I think the value proposition will be an issue, but hope they figure it out.

Nice pizza's New York style. You get a good take out pizza and nice selection. Need to perfect margarita pizza. Mozzarella is more for classic cheese pizza. Like the old fashioned sauce.

The pasta trio is delicious! Probably the best I have had in years. The portions are huge for the pasta plus it comes w 2 garlic knots and a salad. I can't wait to try other items!

Everything we have had is so good. The pastas, the pizzas, and the desserts. We are usually getting multiple things with a family of 4 and after tip we're under $50. The pasta dishes we have gotten come with a salad and garlic knots. They also have a very friendly staff, and the owners are very genuine kind guys.

Not sure what Eric was talking about...this place is phenomenal. Would happily spend the $21 I paid for a large pizza. Might be the best pizza in all of Cincinnati and not sure there's even any places that are close. Garlic Knots were good, and the Tiramisu cake was A+. Will be back

Very good food! The red sauce is amazing!So far I've had the pizza, eggplant parm, spinach roll and meatballs! Everything had been amazing! I can't wait to try the rest of the menu. Please support these guys to keep them in Madeira!!