a pepperoni pizza on a table
a close up of a pizza
Steak Hoagie with Pizza Sauce
Large pizza with tomato and black olives
Pineapple pizza minus one slice
Fried pickles
Night Sticks
Delicious.
Steak Hoagie pickle only
Pepperoni Sausage Bacon pizza
Thomas W.
Feb 19, 2025
Food is good when you fix it to your liking make sure if you like your food well done to ask for they will accommodate you service is a little slow on the delivery side, but you can say that is due to high demand. There is really no ambience besides the area that is in, but it is still a nice place to eat.
Read More
Deana S.
Jul 13, 2020
We love this pizza place. It's probably our favorite. The best part is their mega deal where you get a 2 topping large pizza, night sticks and 2 hoagies. It's only 25.99 and feeds us for multiple meals. Such a good deal! The food is always delicious and fresh. You can get it quickly and you just can't beat the deal! They also do deliver which is a plus if you aren't wanting to leave the house. I am not the biggest pizza craver it's fan but this always hits the spot!
Read More
Rawlins R.
Jul 5, 2016
Stopped by here just before 11 pm on a Saturday. No takeout, so I got delivery.One large pineapple pizza.The pizza arrived and it was delicious. It came with garlic and butter dipping sauces. I would say this is kind of like a local pizza chain option. Papa John's, Dominos, etc.
Read More
Jeff R.
Jun 7, 2018
Where to start... If you've never been to NY city.. don't be fooled here. this is NOT New York pizza.. not by a long shot. I ordered the Mega deal.. which seems like a pretty good deal. You get an XL Pizza with 2 toppings, Breadsticks with cheese and 2 Hoagies... But once you receive the food, then you understand why they can sell it for so cheap. let's start with the pizza.. The dough is flavorless.. and I mean zero taste. it's one of those doughs where you hope the rest of the toppings make you forget all about the part that's holding it all together.Cheese.. well.. it's not a 100% cheese that's for sure.. it's WAY to greasy to be and it has an almost rubbery squeaky texture to it. The sauce is okay.. its the best part about the pizza but even it could use more spices and texture.Also NY pizza comes cut like a pie.. not in squares..The hoagies were nothing but mush.. it's pretty much a cheap version of a JTM patty... and the mushroom sauce nothing but a flavor packet mixed with some gelatin like stuff.. it's pretty much all imitation products.The bread sticks is pretty much a small pizza.. same everything.. only way to give it flavor is to drowned it in the butter sauce that's on the side.I really wanted this place to be good because their isn't many REALLY good Mom and Pop pizza places in Cincinnati.. it's all half a$$ chains with a crap product.. it just blows my mind that someone can just slap NY on a logo and claim to be NY style pizza..
Read More
Tina S.
Jan 1, 2021
I order the cauliflower pizza often and it's delicious and fresh every time! I will continue to support this location. Thanks for all you do
Read More
Will L.
Apr 29, 2020
I want to know, who the fuck is not rating NYPD pizza five stars? It's literally my second favorite pizza on this earth. I'm sitting here on my phone at 4am with no money and in the middle of a pandemic thinking about this pizza.
Read More
Lisa M.
Jul 18, 2020
Best pizza ever, I highly recommend the Italian sub. It's delicious. The delivery was super fast also. This is my new go to!
Read More
Eric R.
Aug 24, 2019
Yum! Ordered a large pep and sausage pizza today - delicious. Also ordered boneless bbq wings - these were good too. Might want to order an XL next time!
Read More
Nancy R.
Feb 6, 2025
It depends on who's working The food and the pricing is not consistent. I like through Peter's.I just wish things for more consistent
Read More
Denise P.
Jul 7, 2024
I ordered a mushroom steak hoagie and it was delicious. I ask for a well done bun but not burnt and it was perfectly cooked , cheese was on the bun melted and yummy. My first time ordering from here but you can count on me being back
Read More