Mikey's Late Night Slice

This place seemed to be "off the beaten path "- but still close to the Findlay shopping area . I'm a visitor and it was my first time trying out this pizza spot . I went for lunch - on a Sunday / I was the only patron , which was surprising to me . Pros : The restaurant itself is massive ; it's covered in fun lights , trinkets , artwork, records , and cool pieces ! Loved the huge sticker collection they have going on . Was nice to walk around a bitand view all the fun things . The pizza slice was honestly fantastic - I liked it a lot .For the Cons : I originally ordered 2 pizza slices and a soft drink My total came to $16.00. !?!? You read that right . 16 bucks for 2 slices of pizza , holy hell . I changed my order to just one slice and the drink . My final total was $9bucks plus a tip *the service the 2 members of staff that were running the place this day were kinda non - welcoming . I would have liked to have had a little more of a "hey how are you , where are you from " type vibe from them Rather than to be kinda feel shooed away like an inconvenience. So I rate this place 3 strong stars for food quality and decor . The remaining stars I couldn't give because of the service , and incredibly high price. However - I would try this place again , and I would recommend it .

A fun spot to stop at during a late night after a concert. The line was long but moved quickly. Pizza slice was big and good. I loved the crust.

We were looking for some late night pizza at midnight and were recommended Mikey's. We were initially planning on eating inside, but the vibe of the place on a Tuesday night was a little creepy so we opted to just take it to go. The service was friendly though. The slices were very expensive at about $6 each. The cheese slice was very good and reminiscent of a classic New York slice. The Mushroom and garlic slice was not as impressive, but still solid. This is a soft 4 star review, but the cheese alone was too good to give Mikey's a 3.

After several beers at Rhinegeist, we wanted pizza. Mikey's Late Night Slice came through!We were wand searched by security before entering, not something I'm used to or expected. They weren't super busy so we walked right up to the counter and ordered. Hubby had the spicy ass pepperoni and cheese with basil. I had the plain ass pepperoni. We shared the cheezy breadsticks.Our order was ready super quick. I thought the pizza was really good! The crust was seasoned nicely and had a perfectly crisp. Good amount of pepperoni as well. The cheezy breadsticks could have used another minute or two in the oven as some of the cheese was not quite melted all the way. I also would have preferred the marinara sauce to be warm.The decor and ambiance was very eclectic but fit the space very well.All in all, great late night pizza in a unique setting! Definitely worth paying them a visit.

If you're going to do one thing, do it right and do it quick. And with that, Mikey's Late Night Slice hits the mark.While I don't know if I'd call this a NYC style slice (its a bit too crispy and doesn't have that "flop" to it), its still a very good slice of pizza. A variety of flavors are available by the slice late into the night, including two vegan options.$5 and change is a bit high for some pizza, but when you are enjoying some libations, I'd much rather have this than the Lunchable-like products other bars serve.

Second time we have tried to eat here. Service is trash. We walked in and nobody was around. Walked to the other side and bartender was in deep conversation with a customer and two other people sitting at the bar. Walked towards the back of this restaurant and still nothing. Walked over to the pizza side and stood for minutes. I could have literally done whatever I wanted to slices of pizza and nobody would know or care. We then walked to other side again, walked past bar and I finally put my arms up to the bartender and asked if anybody works on the pizza side. He then points to the male subject at the bar talking to a female and got his attention. Employee gets up and goes to the pizza side. We walk over and hes just standing there with a spatula waiving for is to come over in a hurry because we inconvenienced his talk at the bar. At that point just annoyed and with little care about service, we did not even try the pizza. Will never go back again. Obviously pour management.

I was meeting my best friend and her family here for lunch. Her daughter has food allergies and this place has really good options for Vegans. I was amazed with the Decor when I walked in. Very open, artsy, eclectic style. I couldn't stop taking pictures. Their pizzas are New York style. I like the fact that their menu super simple. You can either order by the slice or whole pizza. You can build your own and even do half and half. Their vegan section is impressive, including their sauces that come with it. Besides pizza, they have small sides and appetizers. Next to the pizza joint is the bar. Wow! Insanely cool! We ordered the whole pizza so we can take some home. Half cheese basil and garlic mushroom. With it, we ordered a slice of spicy ass pepperoni. My friends ordered half vegan Buffalo chicken/vegan basil cheese pizza. The wait was only 25 minutes. Definitely worth the wait. Omg, the crust was super soft and went well with the vegan garlic butter. The pizzas were very flavorful with the right amount of sauce. Balanced just right. I have to say that this is one of the best pizza joints in the Cincy area. Even the pricing is reasonable. They do offer happy hour and you can order online.The staff was very friendly and attentive. I know we will be back. My Mr and I are now huge fans of this place.

The food was pretty average. The restaurant is half & half with a bar. The vibe & atmosphere is very good and electic. The tall younger dark haired guy that helped us was very nice & joking. Bathrooms were in pretty average condition. All in all it's a good place to come with friends, get messed up and drink!!!!

Around midnight post concert my friend and I were looking for a late night bite - this was open, had good enough reviews, and was an 8 minute walk from our Airbnb. Walking in you've got the bar to the left and pizza counter to the right. When we arrived the line for pizza wasn't too long but when we left it was packed. It did take a while to actually get to place your order but once you do your order comes out within a few minutes. The staff behind the counter was friendly and working hard I just think they need to be provided a more efficient system for taking orders and getting them filled. I was a bit disappointed that they didn't have the pizza of the week available- like I said it was only midnight but they serve pizza until 2:30am. I would've been willing to wait but for some reason it wasn't even being made? Not sure. They also have several dipping sauces for your pizza but the only thing available to try was garlic - another disappointment. I settled for the mushroom and garlic pizza with a side of garlic dipping sauce and an order of cheezy garlic bread sticks. The pizza was good - it's premade and then I think the throw it in the oven for a couple minutes to warm it up. It had a nice char on the bottom and good flavor. The garlic sauce was good - very nostalgic. It reminded me of Papa John's garlic butter sauce which I used to love as a kid. The garlic cheezy bread sticks were out of this world. Delicious, flavorful, and great cheese pull. The decor was neat - I took lots of pictures. They even have an old pay phone for photo ops. The staff was friendly and hard working. My only negative remarks would be the lack of options of things that are actually on the menu.

Delicious pizza, great atmosphere, open late! What more could you ask for?! I highly recommend getting the Unicorn Bar for dessert. You can thank me later!