Mama Nita's
Mama Nita's
Pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, and breadsticks. We get our pizzas with light cheese. Some of its already eaten, of course.
Buffet
a menu on the wall
Napkin holder is nasty
caesar salad
Pizzas
Menu board
Salad bar
Mediterranean pizza
Breadsticks
Ice cream
alfredo pizza
Menu
pizza, food
Menu
food
Linda H.
May 23, 2019
I had a Groupon for $25.00 it only was good for a few weeks and didn't want to loose it so we drove to New Palestine. I read some reviews one said it was next to Subway. Well actually they are both in the same building. Mama Nita's has 7 booth that seat 4 so not much seating. There was a menu board that said all you can eat buffet $5.99 from 11:00 to 4:00.After 4:00 7:49. Kids 2 and under freeKids 10 and under $3.99. Seniors $6.49. Drinks $1.69So I asked if they sold whole pizza he said yes and showed us a menu. Ok there was a lot of stuff on it. A lot of pizza-sandwiches-wings and other stuff. We ordered the buffet and a 12 inch Mediterranean pizza to go. On the buffet a small salad bar with about 12 different toppings bread sticks with cheese sauce and 6 different pizza. The pizza not bad for a pre-made crust. She to top it off you could pick a ice cream treat from the freezer.Ice cream sandwich-bomb pops or popsicles. If ever in New Palestine we would eat here again.
Read More
Tonya F.
Mar 2, 2025
The buffet used to be amazing but that was before the original "new owners" took over. It's terrible now. NOT worth $10. There was hardly any pizza offered and what was there was old. They did not bring out any new even though we requested a simple pepperoni. The staff is so unfriendly. I miss the days of Brody. He was an amazing manager.
Read More
Michelle S.
Feb 7, 2024
My family really enjoys this place. They have a lot to offer besides pizza. They also have a buffet for lunch, that is very good. It is a good place to catch up with friends. The staff are very friendly and courteous. There isn't a lot of seating, but the pizza makes up for it!
Read More
Nahtan R.
Apr 20, 2024
Mana Nita's is a great place to eat pizza and salad with family. The place used to be better before the new owners but that's not saying much. I go this place once a week and have a good meal every time. The service is nice. It is connected to a subway though and I've learned the hard way to not use subways coke machines lol. The ambiance is nice with two tvs one normally with news and one with kid shows.
Read More
Madison S.
May 28, 2022
Got here right at 8:05pm and to my surprise, the cut off for the buffet is 8pm. We asked the person at the counter if it was possible to still get the buffet with what was left (there were still a few mostly full pizzas left!) and the cashier let us participate in the buffet - even at a discounted price! Although the quality was slightly lacking because the pizza was about to be tossed for the night, the flavor was still there! Such a great experience and I greatly appreciate the cashiers willingness to offer us the buffet after hours. I will certainly be returning! Sooo much food at a wonderful price!
Read More
Jeremy B.
Jan 16, 2023
Great Italian sandwich! Simple atmosphere with some seating, but I got carryout. Will definitely be back.
Read More
Ken W.
Aug 6, 2021
First time here as I usually go to Mama Nita's in Greenfield. They kept the buffet fresh and asked if I had a special request. Not too many people eating Buffet but the carry out orders never stopped! There were as many as 8 people working & I mean working. Like a great oiled machine. Back to the food. No complaints here. Good Pizza Mama Nita.
Read More
Kevin M.
Mar 2, 2025
Went for the buffet which was great when Brody managed it a few years ago. He knew us by name, what we liked and made it without asking. Once he was let go and the 2 ladies took over its pathetic. Stopped in today to give them another try and it was awful. Barely anything on the buffet, guy running things was unfriendly. Requested a pepperoni pizza, never got it. Would have had a better meal at Subway for the $20 dollars.
Read More
Craig W.
Mar 1, 2024
You ever been at Subway and lost your appetite after seeing the shiny ham or watery vegetables and thought man I should've gotten pizza but then it's too late? Well not anymore! Just walk a good 15 feet past the register at Subway and you'll find a pizza buffet called Mama Nita's situated oddly in the back of the restaurant. Food: The pizza is actually pretty good, a lot better than you'd think for being in the back of a Subway. Except sometimes they run out if they get a big crowd and you can get stuck waiting for a while. -2 points. Service: The staff is incredibly nice, they are good people. +1 point. Ambience: As mentioned, it's in the back of a Subway, which is convenient when you give up on the Subway Jared diet and need to smash some pizza.
Read More
Linda W.
Apr 24, 2023
Pizza we had delivered was good. Service was good. Ambiance is ok when you use the buffet.
Read More
