Knuckle Sandwich

Knuckle Sandwich is a must-visit if you love classic diners with a fun, nostalgic atmosphere! The 50s-style decor is a blast from the past, with retro booths, checkered floors, and vintage memorabilia that make for a great dining experience.Now, let's talk about the food--WOW. I ordered the pork tenderloin, and it was massive, easily the biggest I've ever seen. Not only was it huge, but it was perfectly crispy, tender, and absolutely delicious. Everything I tried was fresh and flavorful, definitely comfort food done right.The only reason I'm not giving five stars is that the service was just okay. It wasn't bad, but it also wasn't particularly attentive or friendly. Still, the food and atmosphere more than made up for it. I'd absolutely come back for another meal (and to tackle that tenderloin again)!

My husband and I stopped at knuckle sandwich during the week for dinner. Such a cute little place that had lots of old pictures and signs. Service was great, food was really good and a fantastic milkshake for dessert! When my in-laws come for a visit, we will be taking them here.

A southside institution! I had not been since they moved to the new location in Bargersville, and I was nervous that it would be lacking the nostalgic factor I remembered. I needn't have worried. Everything is still amazing! From the decor, to the music, the amazing and attentive waitstaff, to the exquisite food...a truly superb dining experience.

We've been to knuckle sandwich several times two times for lunch and once for breakfast, they were all delicious. I wish I'd taken a picture of the hubcap tenderloin it was delicious for breakfast. We had the pancakes which we split. It was plenty for both of us. I would highly recommend you stop in this family, friendly, 50s. style diner.

Looking for a fun vibe? Knuckle Sandwich is the place! Tons of memorabilia on the walls and TV sets showing old shows like Gomer Pyle. Music on the jukebox has you singing along without even realizing it. After reading other yelp reviews, we decided to share the hubcap tenderloin. It was fully loaded with mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles and a huge beautiful bun. The tenderloin was hand pounded and was a little thin for my taste but it was still delicious. The fries were hot and crispy, a welcome change from cold or soggy fries. I also ordered a milkshake which was served in the metal cup. Other tables had great looking salads and burgers so we will be back. FYI cash prices are listed on the menu, a 3.5% of charge for credit card usage.

Love the atmosphere of walking in to the cool decor Our waitress was helpful with suggestions on what to order. She was on top of our needs. My huge tenderloin was seasoned and battered perfectly. The bun was also amazing as you can see it almost covered the tenderloin. I cut that in half which gave me 2 meals. Can't wait to go back. We were to full to try dessert but the milkshake and sundae looked mouthwatering

Great food...great service!!Clean restaurant and they play the best music. Our bacon was cooked perfectly!!

Love the ambiance. Great fried tenderloin. Unless you're super hungry, you'll be taking some home. Which was good.Great fries - seasoned and super crispy. Double burger was all it should be. Great meat, fresh veggies and tasty bun. Don't need truffle mayo with this one. I'll be going back. So many good things on the menu to try.

Food is excellent and our waitress was the best! This is a hidden little gem in Bargersville!! One of the best family owned restaurants around.

Service was extremely slow, and food was beyond mediocre. Frozen meatballs were as mushy as you can imagine. The only people who would enjoy this place are geriatrics looking for nostalgia. I would not recommend.