Jerry's Pizza

Yes, we recommend having enjoyed for many years both Paint St and Western Ave locations. We've met up with friends on occasion, but must mostly call in pick up orders. You can easily pick whatever crust & toppings you like. The wife and I always order a half & half pizza. The wife is vegetarian & me a caveman meat lover. So both of us get our pleasure. We can never eat a whole medium pizza between us, We always have 2-3 pieces left over each to save for another day leftovers always good. I can vouch that if you get the meat lovers topping you will get tons of the best pizza meats made for a man. LOL

First time in years, and it hasn't changed. Small, cozy, simple, friendly. And good pizza. Kind of different: very thin crust, tiny bits of mushroom and sausage if you get those. We got a pepp, a pepp/sausage/mushroom (PMS,) and a cheese. The kids were torn about the cheese- it had oregano and maybe garlic on top, and they were not fully on board with that. Plain cheese would be best for them. Don't know if they have cheesy bread, or anything besides pizza- didn't bother to ask, don't see a website or any pictures of their menu online. They might have subs or a few other things, but I wouldn't know. Parking is worse than it used to be, but there were spots out front on a Sunday afternoon and it wasn't busy inside. I just picked up, and it was hot and ready when they said it would be. It's not amazing, but it's good, and cheap, and handy. And nostalgic.

Ordered pizza with no mushrooms or green peppers.I got my pizza home mushrooms all over it not happy. Supposed to be ready at 7:30 got it at 7:45.

The pizza was fabulous! The people were amazing. As soon as we arrive, they said they apologized for how loud it was in there. But everybody was celebrating in memory of a friend that they had recently lost. I asked if they needed us to leave since they were all celebrating her and they immediately said oh absolutely not, we would love for you to stay and join us. It was so heartfelt to see all of these people this lady. It was like a family atmosphere. My family truly enjoyed the food I would highly recommend.!!!!

Prices are great !! Pizza was excellent, they are thin crust and rather small. Large is about the size of a normal place medium. House made ranch was incredible!! Only one waitress , but she was wonderful.

Home of the cheeze-it pizza. Not real pizza even though the town rally behind it. Great atmosphere on the weekends more of a hole in the wall with bar flies during the week.

I don't know if it's because I'm an old fat man who likes beer joints and grew up in the country or if it really is the fact that Jerry's on Paint is beside the mill and has the best pizza in the world and some really cold beer... I'm a fan and extroverted supporter of and adamantly in constant need of Jerry's Pizza from Jerry's on Paint. This Jerry's is the original. I'm not referring to Jerry's on Western Avenue, ok.I moved to Chillicothe in 1983 to teach and became acquainted with Jerry's on Paint Street immediately.I cannot tell you anything about the sauce; whether it's made in-house comes out of a can, I can tell you nothing.I can use a lot of adjectives and describe the pizza and all of the toppings that they have available. My description of toppings would discuss how they are chopped in fine little tiny pieces that attempt to roll off as you go to pick up a piece of pizza out of the box.The pizza is cut into strips not in the pie shapes.Jerry's on Paint is small and is always always packed to the brim and once you step inside you will know exactly why.If you are not from Ross County, you may need to ask questions about the history of Jerry's on Paint.If you're asking me questions about Jerry's, you will want to delve into the history of the paper mill right across the street. The two go together just like bread and butter, Johnny and June and Bert and Ernie.I drive from Columbus back to Chillicothe regularly just to pick up pizza at Jerry's on Paint. I told you I'm a big boy so I always get more than one to bring home because there are only two sizes, medium and large, and neither are huge so one is always gone as it sits in the passenger seat of the truck by the time I arrive back home in Columbus.On the bar-type food that they have available, I think you can make a meal out of that section of the menu.Give it a try and take a drive into Ross County, downtown Chillicothe, grab Jerry's and experience downtown Chillicothe.You'll be glad you did trust me. People from all over Jackson, Pike and Scioto counties are hanging at Jerry's.

This Jerry's is definitely a dive bar type of atmosphere, and though my large party had a room in the back, the bar and front seating is what it's famous for. There pizza is unique in that whatever toppings or speciality pizza you order, all the ingredients are finely chopped -- kinda minced texture. The pizza is crispy and they incorporate the sauce with the dough and toppings very well! There's a nice balance of cheese, toppings, and flavor! Be careful though, while the outer ring is crispy and fresh, as you go towards the center, it does get a bit softer (it's still cooked, just not as crispy). They have a unique way of curing the pizza, skinny rectangles! Also, this location is a dive experience, so the decor and cleanileoss is a bit more danky/less polished. They do have another location in the area if you're looking die that family friendly environment!Another note: the large is just $1 more than the medium. Just shell that out and bring some home too :)

Jerry's Pizza at hometown staple most people love it so I made it either and my family we love it. Combination pizza with mild or hot banana peppers is my absolute fave. Something about the crust go get you some you'll thank me later

Negative star review So disappointed Changed a good thing WhyJust not the same won't be back Change the pepperoniChanged sauce Doesn't look or taste the same