Jenny's Homemade Cookies

Jenny's Homemade Cookies are damn good! Are they expensive? You bet. Are they worth it? They're worth every penny!Getting here from our place is a bit of a drive, thankfully! I say that only because if it were closer... well, we'd have eaten many, many more dozen cookies.The store is cute. They had a candle burning, which seems dangerous but it provided a nice scent for the shop.The person working there came out from the back and was very helpful and made recommendations. There's a lot to choose from.These cookies are great for a snack at home and are also great to take to a special occasion / get together.Oh... the cookies. The flavor of each is true to the name and absolutely delicious. Buy what sounds or looks good. I don't think you could go wrong.

My bf and I stopped by here while killing some time before a Reds game. He told me I won't find a better cookie - big statement! I was beyond ready to find out for myself. Upon walking in, I saw a good variety with a few options appearing sold out. A moment later, a woman walked up to the counter, refilling some cookies, including the French toast, which really caught my eye. I asked her if she could tell me what's in it and boy oh boy can this woman sell her cookies with her descriptions! The French toast has layers of streusel and is topped with powdered sugar and syrup. Sold! The bf got butterscotch but also asked about the Millie, which is when we found out this sweet woman was Jenny herself and the Millie is named after her mother. All the feels!We also noticed the business cards' tag line, which said the cookies are so good, they won't make it to the jar. So clever! Jenny told us about being in business for 20 years and how the chocolate chip is the #1 seller; we paid the $8 total for our 2 cookies and headed out. I tried the butterscotch and it was good but that's not my favorite flavor. The French toast however, the bf may have been right, I cannot think of a better cookie I have ever had in my life. WOWZA. It was perfectly soft, slightly chewy, sweet with a hint of salt. I'd drive back to Ohio just for another one. Definitely check this place out and add them to your local place to support list.

Got to meet Jenny this Saturday, working all by her lonesome!! .... Very sweet lady that genuinely welcomes all feedback... I also came to find my new fave cookie butterscotch toffee nom nom sooo good

I should be happy this place is so far from my house or I'd probably weigh 600 lbs. I was excited to find out they delivered (it's a steep fee, but it was worth it) and I ordered a mixed dozen for my birthday celebration. All delicious (chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, oatmeal raisin, peanut butter and peanut butter chocolate chip), but the Sweet Millie is my favorite. Add icing and it's one of the best frosted sugar cookies I've ever had. Love this place and absolutely can't wait to order again!

OMGWe needed a specially designed cookie and Jen hit it out of the park both in design and taste!

The taste here in America is incredible. Definitely brings your taste buds alive. Come try our desserts.

This is the most customer focused company I have ever dealt with Not only are the cookies beyond amazing , but Jennie goes out of her way to make sure that an order is delivered as requestedI can't say enough about the extra steps she took for my particular order --let me just say it was more than anyone could expectPlus I was able to speak directly with her about the order (a novelty these days ) and she was delightful . Arlene D. 10/10/24

Never disappointed in flavor Good service Good location Excellent Tasty food Tasty

Fantastic customer service and the yummiest cookies we've ever had. I don't know if it's possible to find any better! Top notch!

We go to Jenny's to pick up cookies for family dinners, pot luck dinners and of course birthdays. There are so many flavors to choose from and the cookies are so large we cut them into quarters. This allows folks to sample all the different types. Each of our family members has a favorite so it provides a nice variety!! They are in a small storefront and try to keep the cookies stocked in the case. Ask if you don't see what you want as they might have them in the back. There are some seasonal cookies. The folks who work there are friendly and happy to help. Homemade happiness at Jenny's!