Hometown Pizza - Middletown

Lunchtime on Friday soon after opening time so not too busy. Our waitress was very friendly and patient as I had an on the spectrum teen with me to eat. He picked Hometown Pizza and raved about "yellow sauce" and "they hide pepperoni under the cheese". We chose a build your own medium pizza, thin crust. 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 cheese with diced tomatoes. We did the cheese sticks too mainly to appease the hungry teen but I sampled them and they were delicious! Perfectly crisped thin pizza crust for our pizza, and their garlic butter sauce is a great accompaniment. Our drinks got refilled promptly and our waitress checked in to see if we needed anything several times. We paid using the QR code, quick & easy. The big highlight ended up being the 25cent gum ball machine, great timing for cleaning change out of my purse, cheap happiness for the teen guest!

We opted for takeout tonight. My husband ordered online. After arriving home he checked the pizza and the ticket - they didn't match. We'd asked for a thin pepperoni, we received a thick cheese. Thankfully a quick call resolved the error but it did require another drive by. Based on getting two orders, I actually like the thicker crust. Next time I'll also ask for light pepperoni. Having marinara for dipping was good - the pizza itself is light on sauce, too light. Nothing to add about the space since we picked up; however, seating and parking is ample for guests. Most spaces are ideal for 4 people but there are some tables to pull together for a larger group.

This pizza was wonderful! We are all loving how it seems to capture how amazing how Pizza Hut used to be. We got the thick crust extra cheese and a thick crust pepperoni. We loved it and we will definitely be back!

We dined inside for the first time at Hometown Pizza on Wednesday which is family night. (That means free bread sticks for the family with order of a Large pizza)! We had gotten pizza to go before during the pandemic while trying lots of new restaurants via takeout. We love their bacon cheeseburger pizza and dessert pizza!We were delightfully drawn in to the cozy pizza parlor environment. The staff we relaxed and welcoming. It felt very family friendly. We loved the wooden booths and Tiffany lamps. There were lots of kids and it was loud while we were there. However there weren't a lot of screens with ambient noise (which I was thankful for), so the voices of the other customers were not overpowering.The bread sticks were perfectly cheesy. What surprised me most was the chunky marinara. It was so yummy. I don't usually eat marinara because it's often made with tomato paste, but this seemed fresh made and chunky. My kids liked their spaghetti and meatballs. We got the White Chicken pizza and it was very good...as you can probably tell from the picture!

Our quest for the best pizza in Louisville continues. And Hometown Pizza surprised us...in a great way! We ordered the thin crust. One was sausage. The other was mushroom, spinach and onion. The Italian sausage on the pizza was outstanding. I like a little extra sauce. It was tasty. My wife had the mushroom, spinach and onion pizza and loved it. To be honest I think it was the better of the two pizzas. The restaurant is not quiet but definitely not too loud. It is nice that they don't over power you with music. The booths could be more comfortable but I can't remove a star for that. Hometown is a winner. It may still be a quarter star behind the Post but it is the best we have had in Middletown. And by the way...you can go next store to DQ and get a blizzard. Mmmm!

Had a lovely lunch today at Hometown Pizza in Middletown! I'm not a pizza person, I know, GASP! But I'm aways down for a calzone or a sub. Today I had a meatball sub. It was excellent! Came out hot and fresh. Meatballs were a good size, bun was soft but toasted, marinara sauce is chunky with onions and complimented the whole thing. I should have asked about the pasta salad before I ordered as my side, as it's mayo based and I'm not a Mayo fan either. I had a few bites of it though and it had good pieces of olive, onion and pepperoni In it! There were a couple of sliced pickles on the side that I'm mad I forgot to eat! Service by Amy was efficient and pleasant. Def will return here!

I love Hometown Pizza. This location is very nostalgic but recently renovated. The pizza and service is great and personable. Order the Hometown Special and cheese sticks!

I ordered take out from this location tonight and it was great. I got the chicken Alfredo (without the vegetables) which was fabulous as always. It comes baked and tastes so fresh. This is my favorite Alfredo in town by far. I love the garlic bread that comes with it as well! The order was ready on time and correct. The staff were friendly and they were wearing masks. I went in to pick up my order, but they told me you can also get your order curbside if you call and tell them you've arrived. Support this local chain! You won't be disappointed.

Good pizza "joint". Casual. Good food. Family friendly. Prices are good. I would recommend if you just want good pizza and wings

Waited to be seated for the lady to walk away fromUs and seat someone else. Then Waited over 40 minutes for pizza after we got seated and they sent the wrong pizza out. Never brought plates no Parmesan offered either.