Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge

Goodfellas has the best customer service and pizza in town! The pizza slices are giant and they have the biggest bread sticks I've ever seen. 10/10 recommend!

Loved the speakeasy concept. I also loved that the kitchen stays open pretty late; we went at about 10p on a Monday. They offer an array of inventive cocktails which is really neat. The bartender was nice and our drinks were good. The pizza came out hot and fresh. This was just an overall pleasant experience.

There are very few places to get pizza by the slice in Cincinnati, especially slices of this size. I love getting a pepperoni pizza slice with a giant breadstick on the side.I've never had bad service at any location. They also have a rewards program that's great. I got $5 off for my birthday! I think all locations of Goodfellas are great, but this one has the most seating options. More of a family-vibe rather than drunk-2am vibe.

Cool vibe in the restaurant and it's nice that you can get pizza by the slice here. Service is order at the counter and I think there's a bar upstairs you can take the food too.As someone from New York I was excited by the prospect of New York style pizza here in Cincinnati. I was unfortunately sorely disappointed. We got the largest size pizza with sausage. Overall, it was okay. The crust was not remotely crispy. It was quite thick and doughy. We'll probably try them again since they get such good reviews, but so far it did not meet expectations.

I know you think pizza , but you need to know the cocktails are the best! I love that I can patron this place as much as I want because it's close to home. I don't know why I'm finally doing a review but here we are. Service is great rather you get a pizza or go up stairs for drinks. I went on a Wednesday and it was $5 old fashions. They change menu seanallu which keeps me coming back. It's family friendly, and doesn't like huge slices of pizza in warm thin crust? Well I'm sure there are some people out there , but I'm not one of them. Get to pleasant ridge.

Wise guys in pleasant ridge is one of the best Italian pizzeria and speakeasy I have ever been to! When you first walk in you are greeted immediately and offered everything from pizza by the slice, to meatballs and calzones. Then once you wrap up busting the last button on your pants from stuffing your face with a canole go down the hall and up the stairs for a hidden gem. When you walk upstairs you walk into a fully stocked bourbon bar that you don't typically see everyday with some if the most common to most rares bourbon! Make sure to bring your friends and a cigar when it's nice out! Come check this place out!​

We came in at an off time in between lunch and dinner. We did choose two different slices from the case that were warmed up. The slice was good and I bet it was excellent if fresh out of the oven. We also had a bread stick. It could have been fantastic if the sauce to dip in was warm. It was cold.We definitely will be back.

You will be hard pressed to find a better pizza place in the city. Excellent food. Excellent atmosphere. Excellent staff and customer service. The guy working behind the counter was just an all around good guy and made sure we had a good experience.

pizza was just ok, lots of cough not covered by cheese or pepperoni, very little sauce. Unable to receive payment by phone which is unheard of. do yourself a favor and order a real pizza from italianette!

the is place is amazing! the vibes are wonderful, the food is good, and the staff is amazing!! 10/10!! Daniel is the most amazing employee ever!!! he definitely deserves a raise!