Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR

This serves a great purpose in the community. Reasonably priced, nice quality pizza, and fast.I have stopped by twice recently: the first to get my daughter food to enjoy at Pins and the second for a weekday work lunch. In both instances, the line went very quickly and the staff was very pleasant. The pizza itself is above average. I am sure it's better when it's hot... Both times it was a bit lukewarm.. but good. I really like the bread sticks.The weekday lunch special is a really nice value. When I ate there during lunch, I found the restaurant to be clean and the tables upstairs to be spaced out well.

This location just keeps giving and giving... love the multi-levels, patios, and staircases. It's like a labyrinth of pizza! Half-priced Mondays are a steal. 12in pizzas for half price (originally starting at $14). Goodfellas is so, so good. I had ample toppings which can be hard to come by as most local pizzerias are stingy on their toppings. Loooved the nacho cheese sauce option for their giant breadsticks. Customer service was superb from the cashier to the chef. Once they realized they had misread my order, it was very quickly rectified with a huge portion of the topping missed. I couldn't ask for better service. My daughter and I took a trip to the very top level and the views are stunning of Pendleton. The swanky brown couches and rustic wood are gorgeous and elevate the dining experience. I would absolutely bring friends or my husband for a date!

One of my favorite places in OTR. They have a great lunch deal that ends at 3PM with huge slices of pizza that need two plates. The employees were super nice and told me about the upstairs seating. I also tried outside when the weather was warmer.

I've never heard of this place until last night and I think, in my opinion, it's very much a hidden gem in Cincinnati.The food was phenomenal and the atmosphere on the main floor felt like a movie pizza joint! Absolutely stunning! I didn't think it could get any better... and then we went upstairs! The upstairs was beautifully set up with three ginormous shelves of liquor and perfect lighting.Service was great as well! Absolutely would recommend going here!!!!

How do you visit OTR and not swing by Goodfellas?! Pizza is always fresh, salads are yummy and it's all ready to go! Spend as much or as little time here- considering there's a bar on the second floor, there isn't a reason to leave. Employees are always engaged and working hard. The place is small so if you see a line just be patient- the line moves quickly and it's worth it! Pizza by the slice, memories by the handful!

We just stopped in for a slice of pizza and glad we did . The staff was friendly and the slice I had I enjoyed my daughter's slice was to dry for her not enough sauce . My veggie slice was delicious.

I had literally just stepped out of a multiple hour dinner affair at a nearby restaurant but wasn't about to vomit from the quantity I ate so I felt obliged to stop into this place for a slice. There were legit bouncers outside which I initially found intimidating. I didn't realize you had to provide an ID to get pizza. Is that an Ohio thing? Interesting. There was a line but it moved quick. I ordered a classic cheese slice but the bread sticks, which are about as long as GF is tall, were too appealing to pass up. I selected marinara to accompany that shit. I saw somewhere that they are claiming to be NY pizza. I grew up in NY so NY pizza is my baseline. I don't know where it falls on the scale between cincinnati pizza and NY pizza but it isn't NY pizza. It was, however, decent in its own way. Not good enough where I felt compelled to finish it at the time but I did take care of it the following morning. There wasn't nearly enough sauce. I did like the crust, which held up pretty well. There was a flavor that was unique and enjoyable. Ultimately, it was mostly bread and cheese which isn't necessarily a bad thing, just not what I consider pizza.The breadstick was massive and good enough. The marinara sauce wasn't great tho.

Needed a place to grab food before headed to PIns down the road. This was perfect for sharing... pizza and breadsticks for a group of 9. Service was friendly and quick to the point.. how do you want your pie??Def worth the stop

These people are awesome! The pizza is made to order and they have hot slices for pizza lovers on the go! I do like it better than a lot of other brands. The cheese is delicious, I like to add extra sauce to mine! A few times my crust was a little dark, and they refunded me no questions asked! The music and the pictures take you back in time. When I walk in, its almost as if I step out of OTR and into idk.. New York maybe. Main street is such a convenient location. Staff is always friendly and remember to tip!!!!

Loud outdoor music, disrespectful to neighbors. Despite repeated requests, they keep their outside speakers at a high volume.