Colonial Pizza

Listen we're from Jersey, so the standard for pizza is pretty high. However, it got the job done. Flavor was good, crust was nice. But... it was the bbq chicken pizza that stole my heart. Mmmmmm! Delicious even leftover. Town is quaint and service was nice and this is a nice sentimental stop for our family. Our Jersey kids thought the pizza being cut into squares was quite funny.

Alright the food was amazing! Perfect crust! I mean you wanted to eat it all, the sauce so much flavor. Everything you would want when it a local small town pizza place. Atmosphere was great. The servers were nice and quick! Highly recommend!

Finally got a chance to stop in and get pizza a few weeks ago. The other two time we stopped, the place was packed, and so busy we were too busy to wait. Pizza is worth the drive to Cedarville, dough is chewy and had a good bit. I was disappointed with the antipasta salad, I would like a little more meat, cheese on it, and a nicer visual presentation (check out my review of Venecia Italian restaurant)We will defiantly come back, and we have learned to order ahead, and they will likely be packed or busy most of the time.

Coming from someone that works at a pizza place I was reluctant to try this place, but my buddy wanted me to go. I'm glad I did... one of the best places I could have stopped at. The pizza had the freshest toppings in the area, and there was a generous amount of sauce. The wings were as large as my hand and cooked to perfection. Any time I'm in the area I will be returning here.... It's my new favorite

Very good pizza I recommend . The place is very nice , well maintained, decoration is country still, handicap accesible and pet friendly.

Good pizza. The service is good as well. They do offer a rewards program to Cedarville University students. The decor is pretty and comfortable feel.

First time here and found almost everything we tried was good. We arrived before it got crazy with dine in and carry out. We tried the pizza, two different subs, potato skins and mozzarella sticks. The pizza is a hand tossed crust with great flavor, the sauce is a sweet sauce. The only thing we tried that we didn't like was the mozzarella sticks they were baked and not long enough for the cheese to get hot and melted.

We have been long time customers. Colonial is expensive so we do not order often. We just ordered this evening to support a fundraising event. We got an 18" BLT pizza. It was inedible. It tasted like bacon bits piled on crust. The bacon bits were held together with cheese and kept falling off of the crust. There was way too much "bacon" on it and it was teeny tiny crumbles. I'm positive it was bacon bits or bacon cooked in bulk one day a week, chopped up and refrigerated. $30 bucks down the drain because we couldn't even chew it! Colonial used to have nice large chunks of bacon on the pizza- not teeny crumbles of dry unchewable bits. I left my review at 4 stars because one bad experience doesn't mean I'll knock off more than one star. We will not be ordering any time in the near future, though

Good pizza. I could have ordered better, perhaps. We ordered 2 large pizzas, One more traditional and one without meat and low dairy. The regular pizza was as expected. Eaten quickly by teens. The veggie pizza was unremarkable... now... maybe I should have tried harder to find out if there were other veggies I could have added... like banana peppers or jalapeño peppers, more bell peppers or whatever, but as is, it was a bit boring. But- that may have been my fault! My recommendation- give it a try! But if you want a veggie pizza- try to see what additional veggies you can add to flavor it up. As for advice to the business, I would suggest to try hard to feed your plant based customers well- lots of veggies on veggie pizza- because those plant based eaters might be the mom who pays the bill. I'll try this again in the near future- and advocate for more veggies when I place my order. Thank you to colonial for making our dinner on a busy day!

Colonial Pizza has friendly staff and great pizza! Their dough is make in-house freshly every morning, which makes for some amazing pizza, breadsticks, and more!