Carlos Pizza

DO NOT GET CHEESE PIZZA HERE. I did this the first 3 or 4 times I went and always hated it so I thought the place was bad. Eventually I decided to get the pepperoni pizza and it is 100% better. The grease from the pepperoni flavors the pizza and is very good. The staff that works here are also great. They're friendly and it makes for a nice dining experience. Their restaurant itself is inside a dead mall sadly, but it's still a nice place!

Well I hate to say that I've lived in Columbus for 32 years and had never eaten here until today! I've become friends with an Italian couple from New York and asked them this "you guys are from New York and Italian, so what's the closest to New York pizza in Columbus Indiana?" Without hesitation they both replied Carlos Pizza! I had to ask where it was. So today my wife and I tried it. Absolutely outstanding!! Pizza, salads, and pepperoni breadsticks were absolutely delicious. Plus one of the cheaper lunches in town. If you like Pizza and breadsticks you have to try this place. Definitely 5 stars

I went here today based on the 5 star reviews. The sausage on the pizza was spoiled. This is the worst pizza I have ever eaten. Frozen store bought pizza is better. Better yet boxed chef boyardee with the powdered cheese taste better than this. 17.57 wasted. The 5 star reviews must have been from family. Never again will I eat this pizza, if I ever come back to Columbus.

I love Carlos pizza. They have really good prices and every meal fills me up. Their stuffed pizza is a meat lovers dream and their pepperoni stuffed breadsticks are awesome. Really recommend this great local joint.

This is a hidden gem in the old mall with very friendly staff and amazing and huge pizzas!!! It was very clean as well. We ordered a large pizza and it was easily 20 inches. We dined in and took the rest home to enjoy tomorrow. We will definitely be back.

Carlos pizza, when eaten straight from the oven is hands down the best pizza in Columbus, IN. It's a small place in the mall run by only a few guys. All of them are very customer led and fast to address any need that you have. Very hard working staff which has been the same group for years. It's rare to find folks with the same business this long and that work very hard. Pizza wise, cheese or pepperoni is their strength. As you add more toppings it just doesn't taste as good. Again, fresh from the oven is great and that is when it's the best pizza in Columbus. Foldable crust. At lunch, I've seen them reheat slices and that is still ok but not as stellar as fresh pizza. I always order their pepperoni breadsticks which are also great. They also have salads made to order which we occasionally get. If you are thinking of ordering take out give them a try.

Carlos is the best always timely, kind, and friendly. Pizza and breadsticks always taste great and never a long wait!

Great pizza!! I love their friendly attitude. They are doing great with this crisis. The workers always seems to be happy and ready to work and make pizza. I would recommend the Hawaiian Pizza with Pepperoni breadsticks. It's my go to meal.

Well no workers were wearing a mask. Also they took out a 10$ tip for even though I gave no tip. I only ordered 18$ worth and he pulled out a 10$ tip. The food wasn't as great as it used to be.

Always delicious, never had a problem! Always friendly, quick, and fresh! You can't bet the prices with the large pizzas! Kiddos love it!