By Golly’s

Had the cheeseburger pizza during pizza week and it was delicious! Tried the fish, waffle fries and Cole slaw. Fish was ok, I wasn't a fan of the Cole slaw as it had some unique almost bitter taste.

Had a great time here. Lots and lots of TVs for the games!!!!Great staff. Especially the cute little girl Kayla who brought us our food and recommended the cheeseburger quesadillas!!!!

This place used to be The Varsity, which okay. The new owners have cleaned it up, gave it better lilighting and just gave it a better look. I started with jalapeno poppers. They were crispy on the outside and mildly molten inside. By themselves, they were good. But, they are served with Ranch dressing and that was a little weird. Next I had the bacon cheeseburger. Super juicy, very tasty, it was a great choice. Our server, Morgan was friendly and attentive. Keeping in mind this is still a sports bar, the noise level could be a bit loud, so choose your table wisely. All in all, there will likely be a return visit.

August 17.Visited the new By Golly location on Beechmont for the first time. We ordered a pizza billed as 'Our Famous' Cheeseburger Pizza. It was brought to the table quickly and hot. The ingredients were fresh and properly prepared. It was simply excellent and something worth returning for. The service was prompt and attentive. The sports bar atmosphere is a bit noisy (as expected) but the background music was loud enough that normal conversation was difficult. Background music should be just that, background. It should not impede normal conversation. I'll return to this restaurant again once they have been open for a while and they've smoothed out the bumps that always pop up when opening a new restaurant. For sure this place is worth a try.

When I heard a By Golly's was opening on Beechmont, I was rather stoked, because I really enjoyed their location in Milford and expected a similar great experience in this one. Maybe the staff is just too new because that's not necessarily what happened there. The food was just okay, the service was lacking, and even the atmosphere seemed incomplete. Honestly, I think they rushed to open before they were ready.I went with my work crew on a Thursday for lunch. It was a bit busy but not completely packed. The place itself was formerly Varsity and it looked like they'd just repainted everything white ane grey. I hate to say it, but it felt stale and boring, no personality unlike the original location. We were sat right away by a very friendly hostess. The menu was pretty much the same as the original location so I had an idea of what to expect. However, we sat for a good 20 minutes before anyone approached us for drinks, and I watched a few servers stand around the front by the host stand just talking non-stop so it's not like they were understaffed. Looking around, I could tell that everything was not ready to go, as they still had someone working on the iced tea maker. As for our food, we started with an order of pretzel bites while we were deciding on our main courses. It took another 20 minutes to put that order in and our drinks were empty because no one came for that either. Luckily, the pretzel bites didn't take that long, and overall were pretty good. As for our order, my coworkers both did a build your own burger, one with straight fries and one with waffle fries, while I had the buffalo chicken wrap with steamed broccoli. It must've taken 40 minutes for the whole order and they brought chips instead of fries for both my coworkers. They fixed that quickly though. Everything looked pretty good, but taste-wise, was just okay. Nothing too impressive, especially for Anderson Township, which is brimming with good lunch/dinner options. I was honestly a bit disappointed in the whole experience, especially the wait, but I understand that they just recently opened up. They might have needed to train their staff a bit more instead of rushing to open so fast. Maybe things will be better if I give it another shot later on but I almost don't want to give it another go. I don't EVER like to speak poorly of a local business but this place needs work in many ways. I really hope they're able to fix the flaws and become a better addition to the area. It shouldn't take an hour and a half to have a relatively simple lunch.

TERRIBLE. this place we've now tried 4 times. Food has been up and down / very inconsistent. Beer... they may have it / maybe not, tonight the beer was oddly sweet and wrong... kinda weird. Switched to bottles..... still paid for it even though only drank half of it. No biggie........Play Keno... NO cash to pay out on ANY amount. Play music on TouchTunes...they shut music off with no warning because the 'big game' is on. Some crappy college football game. Dirty lines for the beer... tasted very 'off' and 'sweet'. Yuck. And to finish... you will 'enjoy' your experience with a group of fruit flies, they are friendly but very annoying.

Have been waiting for this restaurant to open, we loved the Milford location. We got two different sandwiches and split them. I tried one bite of each and was very disappointed. My husband got the Saratoga chips, they were very pale and didn't have much flavor. The hoagie seemed over seasoned, too much salt. Not sure if it was the meat or the sauce. The Italian sandwich was so-so, plus we could see it sitting in the kitchen for quite a while before they served it. Might have tasted better when it was hot still. Got the fries with that and was the best tasting of anything we had that night. My husband is not a picky eater, eats anything, but when he said he wouldn't go back again, I knew it was bad.

My husband and I were out and about tonight. We love to eat at places that aren't a huge chain. As we were heading down 125 I searched for restaurants near me. This place popped up. The name grabbed me and there we went. We got there kind of early. The music was spot on for us. Our era, and found out that they have theme nights. Our waitress came back to the table and said, sorry I was trying a new burger. I asked, does it have peanut butter? Crazy!? They are working on a bacon jam and they just did a Buckeye burger for the big Buckeye/Notre Dame game. Joe the GM brought me a taste of the bacon jam and it was really good. The spice gets ya at the end. We will definitely be back for Trivia night! As usual, I only give a 4 star because there's always room for excellence.

The By Gollys located on Beeechmont Ave is infested with roaches!! The restaurant is well aware and ignores you when you tell them. this place needs to be closed down, roaches on the floor, the walls, by drink machines, just nasty.

They took The Varsity and slapped some white, green and orange paint on it and that's about it. The white paneling and ceiling lights on the upper deck are reminiscent of a manufactured home. The bar tender/waitress we usually get on the lower level is awesome. She's awesome. The food is good. I think it's way better than the Varsity. Burgers are my fav item. Reasonable pricing on meals and drinks. The one thing I'd recommend they improve is the water. It's the most god awful tasting water I've ever had. I actually pack a bottle of water when we go watch Bengals games.