Black Sheep Pizza

Unique and delicious pizzas, good ambiance, comfortable setting, friendly and knowledgeable staff. We will be back!

This is a really nice spot with a good location. I look forward to returning so I can try some other items from the menu. I love what they have done with the renovation as well.

Food was good! The smoked burrata was good, but needs more bread. Their Pécora Nera Pizza is really good! Drinks on the higher end and small.

Wonderful fire roasted pizzas and italian items. The crusts / bread items are all baked perfectly. The sauces and dressings all balanced for savory and sweet. Atmosphere is modern and warm. Looking forward to dining here regularly in the future. (Meatballs are amazing, definitely get them). Great service from the staff.

Service was good. A group of us ordered meatball piadinas and none of us were impressed with the sandwiches. We all thought they were flavorless and over cooked. We may return later but doubtful.

Love the vibe, location, and ambiance of this place. Food was delicious. But service was terrible. I'm really not that person. I'm easy to please. We sat at the bar, which is fairly small, so it's not like he didn't see us. Got us drinks fairly quickly. Mine was meh. Friend's was great. Asked for water twice; he said sure thing both times but never got it. Dude was literally four feet away. He was fairly busy making drinks for the tables, but still. We had to ask someone else. He never asked how our food was and never asked if we wanted another drink. Maybe he was having a bad day, but clearly not the vibe we expected when we sat down.

Food is consistently delicious. Thanks for offering additional bread with the Burrata appetizer. Chopped Salad is fabulous. Service is excellent- so friendly and smart with recommendations when asked. Appreciate the attention to special requests made when booking a reservation. Love the energy. A most favorite place.

Great vibe in this restaurant, and it came recommended to me. I was very excited to try a pizza with pistachios on it, as it was a new combination I hadn't thought of. Unfortunately, all the flavors / toppings were concentrated at the very center of the pizza, but then the whole outer ring was really quite bland. My Old Fashioned was very strong, so that was a bonus. Service was honestly atrocious. We were encouraged to sit at the bar, as it is "full service". However the three bartenders/servers behind the bar just reallllly did not want to sell us things. lol. Multiple times we flagged them down for the same thing, they'd nod and say they'll go get it / refill it, and just.... didn't? It was one of the only times in my life I have only tipped 10%.

Food was great, fabulous crust on the pizza. Our service was excellent with a very attentive waitress, however the atmosphere was very loud and didn't need the music in the background to make it noisier. We will definitely be back because the food was great!

The Ambiance is perfect! Love brightness and looking out the windows! Service is great! The oven is amazing. Prices are reasonable. We really appreciate the hours they are open. Starting at 11:00. We are so excited to have a place like this in Columbus. Congratulation's to the creators!