Bentino's

Very good pizza and garlic knots! They even delivered to John Bryan State Park which was a huge plus!

The place is one of those quintessential holes in the wall, but you know those are some of the very best foodie places. Bentino's is no exception. The place is just your average decor, but it's hopping crazy with take out orders and in and outs, which is all great clues for the food! We stopped because we all wanted pizza or something close. Jackson got pizza and Shidela and I did calzones. We also started with cheese breadsticks. OBTW the breadsticks are yooge, and meal all by themselves! We ordered and grabbed sodas from the fridge and waited for our stuff to come out. Along our wait, we sat back and enjoyed the wonderful smells coming from the kitchen ... and the near constant take-out they were doing! We underestimated our capacity of all the great food and tho we took stuff home, the food was just outstanding. You know how when you take a bite you can taste the freshness and the love and care that went into it all?, well that's what we tasted here! This is clearing some of what brings people back! Yes, we'll be back too! Just lovely and the service was superb too. I recommend stopping by when you can. It's right downtown and be careful or you'll miss it. That'll be on you of course, because the place is totally awesome. Don't judge this book by its cover! You'll be sorry if you do! Trust me. We'll be back for sure.

We were in yellow Springs and thought we would try this place and we are excited that we did. This pizza is very good. We got the Greek and it was very tasty and the vegetarian they allowed us to do half-and-half. And we used their great coupon for a medium pizza for 5.99. The location is pretty tight parking in the front and you walk in the side door. If you are parked elsewhere, you can walk to the place and eat. We ate inside and it was very nice and clean with standard seats and tables. This place is handicap friendly. Very nice service too and attentive. We would definitely come back. This is the type of pizza you eat when you want comfort.

Great pizza. We had the thin crust and it was delicious. We had one of their specialty pizzas. When we return to Springfield we will stop again.

A great local place in yellow springs. The service was quick. Limited seating in the restaurant. There are no restrooms. Got the chicken ranch and the Greek both were really good. The spaghetti was also very good a bit on the sweeter end. The cheese was really good. One of the best marinara. The garlic bread was crispy and flavorful. I would highly recommend this place.

I don't think I've had a bad pizza at Bentino's. Love the chicken ranch. Love the Greek pizza. Especially like the coupons--check out the one for a free calzone if you spend a certain amount. The calzones really are delish. The marinara is yummy. Go big or go home and add extra cheese.

Went on a day trip today to the charming town of Yellow Springs. Love the city btw. We walked in Bentinto"s and the young lwoman at the register never smiled or greeted us. She just looked at us and told us there were menus on the counter and on the tables...soooo, we sat down on seating that the coverings (fake leather) were split and very worn out. We decided what we wanted to order and waited ten minutes. The person at the register just kept flipping her red ponytail, checking her phone and watching a weird show on tv. She looked in our directio once, never asked if we were ready to order, if we wanted something to drink or tell us that we had to order at the. counter if they don't take orders at the table. We're not psychics. We should have known from the outside of the building that this place is a dump. Peeling paint, and Just a nasty looking building and parking lot. Gross place.

Great service. The food was pipping hot which is a good thing. Cheese ravioli was excellent and do yourself a favor and get extra garlic bread.

Bentino's has my favorite pizza in the area, better than any of those chains in my opinion. They do delivery and the drivers are always amazing. They are supposedly expanding into the vacant space next door to it, so I'm guessing there will be more space to sit down. I have never had a bad experience with an employee and I've been going here for years. It is a place where you have to go to the counter and order and they don't bring you your drinks, but that seems kind of obvious to me since there's so little space and the drink fountain is placed in the seating area where customers access it.

The pizza was good. We ate there when we arrived to Yellow Springs on June 10. My only issue was with the attitude of the girl taking orders. She wasn't bad With us, but some patron came in to pick up his pizza and after he left, she was bad mouthing him loud enough for customers to hear.