Spiro's Hilltop Fish Fare & Steakhouse
Spiro's Hilltop Fish Fare & Steakhouse
Half BLT sandwich and side Caesar salad combo, $10.99
Grouper tacos with mac-n-cheese (my side choice), $10.49
Calamari appetizer
Half BLT sandwich and side Caesar salad combo, $10.99
Bar booth seating
Grouper tacos with mac-n-cheese (my side choice), $10.49
Changing table in women's bathroom
Dessert case
Old fashion
Gin martini
Cosmo martini, yum!
Hours
Shrimp cocktail, not worth getting
Bar
Bathroom
Surprisingly fresh buffet especially the ocean perch
Strawberry smash
Menu
Outside
Outside entrance
Drink menu
Menu
NY strip steak, side of garlic mashed potatoes
Peter M.
Jan 30, 2025
We have dined here for lunch several times over the past couple of years. Each occasion provided a convivial experience with the food commensurate with the price. What's not to like?While not gourmet fare, both the AYCE and off-the-menu entrees deliver as promised. My kinda place.Looking for a straight-up restaurant that meets your expectations? Has my "Give 'em a Whirl" meter heading back for more shrimp on the AYCE bar. Mmmmmm!
Read More
Kaylea J.
Feb 8, 2025
We live an hour away and always try to make an effort to come to this restaurant at least twice a year as it is one of our favorite places to eat! We've never been let down here. The food is absolutely amazing. The service is fast as well. One of our favorite places that we always recommend to other people!!!
Read More
Kerry Q.
Jun 26, 2024
We went last night for dinner and left disappointed. The front of the house staff couldn't be nicer and made us feel very welcomed. Our waitress was really nice and attentive. The problem was with the quality of the food. We haven't been here in over a year and it seems some things have changed. Dinner started off promising with quick drink service and great Caesar salads. The hot bread was lovely but it being served with dirty bread plates was not. My husband said his prime rib was tough but edible. My fettuccine Alfredo with chicken was bone dry, like it was made and sat for 20 minutes under a heat lamp. The strange thing was although the outer layer was warm, the middle was cold and congealed. The chicken looked like it was scraped off a grill also with anything else on there. I picked at it but couldn't eat it. Our waitress apologized and offered to get me something else but by that point my husband was done eating so I would have sat there eating while he just waited for me. Not exactly my idea of having dinner together. We got the check and we were not surprised to see the fettuccine alfredo still listed on there, because no offer was made to remove it although I didn't really eat it. I'm not going to have it out with a manager over 20 bucks but seriously, if people can't eat your food, take it off their check. We won't be going back. We should have known when we pulled into an empty parking lot that it was a sign that we shouldn't eat there.
Read More
Tanya O.
May 1, 2024
Overall food was good. Service was good as well. Wasn't too crowded. Didn't feel rushed. Granted I went on a Tuesday. I got blackened prime rib. Didn't care too much for the sides. My husband got the shrimp scampi and also enjoyed it.
Read More
Janelle S.
Jun 27, 2023
New to the area & wasn't sure what to expect, happy to find a new go to dining spot. The food was good, a few hits & a few misses, but still would have me returning! The hits: calamari appetizer was crispy & delicious, the NY strip steak was cooked to our liking and side dishes yummy. The cheesecake was creamy and def the dessert to get. The misses: shrimp cocktail was limp & watery, felt like it was poorly defrosted from the freezer. Would skip next time. The steak & shrimp scampi dinner was underwhelming. Steak was thin so hard to cook more on the rare side & shrimp, an addition of linguini would improve it. The chocolate cake was dry & only saving grace was stealing strawberry topping from the cheesecake. Service both at the bar & in the dining room was great, although bartenders were a little slow once we weren't the only patrons at the bar. Their bread served warm with dinner gets a special shout out. It's the closest thing to bread from NY/NJ I've found down here! They get it from a Greek wholesale bakery (Artos Bakery) in uptown area, but do sell the small loaves for $4.99 if you wanted to take one home!Feels more like a NJ diner then a fancy steakhouse, but I'll be back with the family next time and get a few extra loves of bread to bring home!
Read More
Sherry P.
Apr 11, 2024
I went to hill top this evening! The service was great but the food was not! I just told my server to take it away! The manager came back to my table, brought my entree and said " what is wrong with this"? I felt I was being attacked. She was belligerent and I didn't like it! My salad had frozen cucumbers on it. The broccoli was cold and barely cooked. The flounder(filet) had skin on it and was totally disgusting! She took the fish off check but charged me for broccoli ( I didn't eat) and the salad ( I ate but took frozen cucumbers off of it)! I won't be back!!!! And I will tell all my friends at the hospital how I was treated!
Read More
Ryen S.
Sep 19, 2022
I'm not usually a harsh critic, but this place is absolutely dreadful. Took the family out for dinner and every single one of us had gross food.My wife's baked potato was never washed, and had literal dirt inside it and on the skin. I thought it might be charred or something so I tasted it... nope, 100% dirt. (Added a pic of the dirt we wiped off below)I got the chicken parm, and it was teetering on the edge of edible. It was cooked fine, it was just very below average. I was hungry so I ate it anyway. The chicken parm is $30 btw.Then we got the "famous" 7 layer cake for desert. $10 for a slice by the way!! It was bland and drier than Queen Elizabeth herself. I'll never understand how a restaurant could put out food like this. Disgraceful.
Read More
Mathias L.
Jan 15, 2025
The service is always impeccable at Hilltop. The food is good and the prices are very reasonable for the quality of food that you get. Can't go wrong with the Prime Rib, Delmonico Ribeye, or any of the seafood specials.
Read More
Dallas J.
Jun 10, 2024
Always love Hilltop! My kids always want to go. They love the buffet and the food on the menu. Sometimes it's really nice to have a great family restaurant, a Fish Camp, and a steakhouse all rolled in to one large restaurant that still feels like home. And the traditional old southern restaurants with great food facility, and friendly service. Lunch buffet is great for quick bite sit down and go. Dinner can be easy or as complicated as you choose. They keep a lot of stuff on the menu. The seafood is as good as at any beach place. Steak is pretty awesome too. The Greek and Southern food is second to only your granny's kitchen. Reminds you of back home.
Read More
Amber O.
Aug 13, 2024
Portions are small. Definitely don't get what you pay for. We went with a party mostly senior citizens. Added gratuity to check most of the younger generation know to look for but most seniors paid double tip. They act like it was inconvenient that we needed an extra space for 1 more person when we paid extra for a room. Waitress made it seem like it was a bother when you asked for something. I won't be back wasn't impressed. But you can try your luck if you want.
Read More
