Seemingly Overzealous Ice Cream

I cannot say enough great things about Seemingly Overzealous Ice Cream! As a big ice cream lover myself, I was worried about the overhype of this place but they rose to the challenge. Seemingly Overzealous provides dairy, egg, and gluten free ice cream making it inclusive for people with dietary constraints. They have a colorful and funky marketing style which makes the space fun and lively. Their shop in Camp North End is fairly small but the line is worth the delicious flavors! I got two scoops: chocolate with cookies and cream. I can't wait to try this businesses new location that recently opened in Plaza Midwood!

Everything is better with ice cream + knowing that there isn't any dairy to make me regret the ice cream in the first place. I appreciate when flavors rotate. Ube cheesecake was my winner of the night and I can see how it was voted back by customers. I've been thinking about the next time I'd be back since the last time I was there. I guess that means I'll be there tomorrow.... Now to decide which flair to get.

Amazed that this ice cream (or technically, "non-dairy frozen dessert") is entirely dairy, egg, and gluten-free! For the amount of creaminess and flavor, I could have sworn I was eating plain ole ice cream.Conveniently located inside Camp North End (which has free 3-hour parking in the garage), Seemingly Overzealous is a cute scoop shop with brightly-colored décor and some seating both inside (bar stools against the windows) and outside (benches with a fun ice cream drip design).Upon entering, a friendly staff member asked if we'd visited before. No? OK well then you get the full spiel! First, go to the cash register. Let them know how many scoops you'd like, and pay. Next, slide over to the left, and try all the samples you'd like at the counter before making your final selection! And they weren't kidding: we were encouraged to try as many as we wanted, which was so nice when it seems like more and more ice cream shops are cutting down on samples or make you feel bad about wanting to try more flavors. Everything we tried was so tasty, and we ultimately went with 2 scoops: peach cobbler & brown sugar cinnamon. These went so well together! The staff explained that the peach cobbler is a new & improved recipe since they'd received feedback from customers that they wanted more peach, and it delivered! The brown sugar cinnamon was chock full o' flavor and tasted like Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Seemingly Overzealous is a dream for those with allergies/food restrictions -- and for those who just love great "non-dairy frozen dessert!"

Looking to cool off in this "Not Quite Summer" heat, then look no farther than Seemingly Overzealous! They have the most delicious flavors of ice cream, and everything is dairy, egg, and gluten-free! Healthy and tasty is a combo I can definitely get with. Located in Camp North End, it will definitely be a visit I'll make often when I'm visiting the QC.My boys and I were lucky they were open for Memorial Day. The owner and his daughter were the perfect host to our curious needs. We were able to sample flavors before deciding on our final selection. Oli was able to practice her first scoop with my selection, and she did an excellent job! I was afraid she was giving me too much and was going to be fired her first day on the job. But dad was pleasantly pleased as well. I went with Papercup Love Notes (coffee) + Easy to Please (vanilla). Darius had Is This My Life (tumeric, cinnamon, ginger, blk pepper, nutmeg, roasted coriander, and honey) + The Dinner Rule (peanut butter w/Oreos). DeAndre chose Never Tear Us Apart (butter pecan) + I Needed Someone to Feed (brown sugar, cinnamon, like cinnamon toast crunch milk). We were able to sample each others and I must say, they all were delicious! Looking forward to trying them again!

Stumbled upon this location during an afternoon strool. Nice options on a warm day. Along with a good portion. Most certainly will return

Delicious vegan ice cream with a bunch of flavors. I don't remember what I got because the names are kinda long but I got two different flavors and they're both amazing

Ice cream is overly sweet for my taste. The flow/logistics of the service is ridiculous. The line start with ordering the ice cream. For first time customer, it's hard to order one without seeing what flavor are available to order (not everyone can scan to see their flavor), let alone sampling it. The poor logistics/flow of this tiny place makes it even congested. We will not come back here or recommend this place for the ice cream and service.

You would never guess this place is dairy-free! The person running the store was super helpful and informative. They had an upbeat attitude and clearly enjoyed assisting first-time diners.

I love Seemingly Overzealous. I live around the corner & have been visiting since the weekend they opened. I don't normally gravitate towards non dairy ice cream but this one is oat milk based (I believe!) and so creamy you can't tell. They're always doing unique flavors so there's something new to try. I'm also a sucker for the branding, their shop is bright & colorful featuring different emotions. My favorite flavors are "Easy to Please" which is a vanilla that tastes kinda like lucky charms & "Grumpy & Lumpy" Ube. Tonight I tried the chocolate chip ube cookie sandwich & to be honest when I looked at the thin cookies I didn't have high hopes. But SO came through again, Great flavor & perfectly chewy. Long story short. There's a lot to love here, not the least of which is the wonderful staff. So stop by, eat a cone while taking in Camp North End views or grab a pint to go with your other treats.

I usually hate non-dairy ice cream, but I wanted to try a local spot. I love their unique flavor options. While I can't say I liked this as much as dairy based ice cream, it was very good for non-dairy ice cream.