Pizza Baby

I decided to try Pizza Baby after looking at the pictures and reviews of their mortadella sandwich. I had very high expectations going in, but after arriving, I realized that my expectations would be exceeded very shortly. As planned, I ordered the mortadella and burrata sandwich. It was promptly delivered to my table, and it was beautifully toasted. After just one bite, I realized that this sandwich was truly special and elevated the ingredients such that you would have thought you were sitting in a café in Florence. It was expertly prepared and made the most of the mortadella. It was paired beautifully with the arugula while the burrata added luxury to and already incredible sandwich. Since the experience with the sandwich was so good, I had to try a slice of the Roman pizza. I am sure their American style pizza is great, but under no circumstances would I order anything but the Roman style. I had the Sicilian, which was the perfect marriage of ingredients and took my breath away. This lunch was accompanied by a Caesar salad that was also expertly prepared. I could not give this restaurant a higher rating. While I was there, I met the owner and he was incredibly personable and clearly has a passion for what he does. This will become a place that I routinely revisit.

The Pesto Pistachio Focaccia Pizza is what lured me in and it did not disappoint. It was delicious! It's by the slice so it's pretty good size for $11.00. The wings were good too with just the right amount of spiciness, but they're VERY overpriced at $16.00! We ordered ONE bottle coke $5.00 and took home a dessert $10.00. Over $60+ for a lunch experience is very expensive and takes away from the good experience, because you leave feeling ripped off. The service is VERY slow and it seemed like they only had one server (WAH) and she is NOT efficient at all and cannot multitask. You can tell she becomes overwhelmed with simple tasks. It's just pizza and sandwiches, the service shouldn't be so slow. Overall, we would return, but only for pizza and water, cuz it's just too freakin expensive! The ambiance is a bit crowded and the layout seems cluttered.

Have been here twice now and have had great meals both times. The pizza is consistently delicious and I enjoyed the mortadella sandwich recently. Great low-key date night spot!Small tables

I ordered sandwiches from Pizza Baby for a birthday celebration and the entire process was easy and stress-free! Steven and Tory were great to work with and the sandwiches were a hit! Everyone wanted the contact information to use them for their next event.Give them a try today!

Italian cafe setup in Elizabeth serving focaccia bread pizza? Yes please! Park on the nearby lots or on the street and you're in for a treat.Walk in to a small cafe with a bar and you're greeted with a smile. The wall is full of wine and olive oil which set the vibe of the restaurant. Sandwiches and shareables were available but I was here for the pizza. Focaccia bread gives a thicker base which holds up to the unique combinations. The tartufo with pine nuts and truffle cram offers a great combination- not your traditional slice but something delicious and memorable.If you're seeking unique combinations and a memorable, slower experience spend some time at Pizza Baby East.

This place is amazingThis was my second visit. The menu can be confusing for pizza but they take their time with you to make sure you get what you wantThe Roman style pizza is my favorite I took it home for my wife to try and then brought her back and we enjoyed it fresh together The bread and much more is all made in house They have draft beer , wine and cocktails. My wife had the espresso martini and loved itTheir cheese is so good The wait staff is great as well

Pleasantly surprised! The pizzas are huge and the food was very good. Our server was wonderful and she be a reason to go back! It's a small restaurant and dark, it's a very romantic feeling and we would go back for sure

First time here and can't wait to go back! Atmosphere was lovely, great outdoor eating area, super friendly service, delicious food!

Pizza Baby East is OUTSTANDING. And this is coming from a gal who doesn't eat pizza or sandwiches very often because of the carbs and calories.My husband and I went there for lunch on a quiet Monday. I had the Mortadella, Burrata, and Arugula sandwich with their daily side, a Caesar salad. My husband had the Roman-style (i.e., single slice) Sicily pizza, with added pepperoni. Even though they make their sliced pizza fresh to order, we only waited ten minutes for our lunch. While my husband usually favors thinner crust pizzas, he loved the Roman-style thick crust at Pizza Baby East. It was very crispy, and the toppings were just perfect (especially the mortadella and chili oil!). His pizza was cut into two large pieces that were a perfect portion for him. For $10 (plus $2 for the added pepperoni), this was a great lunch deal. My sandwich was served on crispy homemade bread, with lots of arugula. The pesto and burrata added great flavor, and I only wish there were a little more of these two ingredients. Regardless, my sandwich was absolutely amazing. The salad was similarly good, made with obviously homemade dressing and crispy croutons. Their portions are generous, and I took half of my sandwich home. This sandwich was absolutely worth the $14 cost, including a side.The staff were very friendly, and the chef even came over to see if we were enjoying our lunch. We responded with a resounding YES. FYI - if you order a Coke, you'll get a bottled version from Mexico. Yay - no high fructose corn syrup in their Cokes!Parking is easy (and free!) in the large lot across the street. We'll definitely return!

I'm always up for trying different types of pizza and I was able to check this place out during the week. This location serves what they call a Roman style pizza by the slice using house made focaccia bread and the Americana pizza using cold fermented pizza dough both free of additives/preservatives and seed oil free. I ordered the Queen margherita(red base, pesto, mozzarella, basil) and the crust was light and fluffy but crunchy....not sure how to explain but everything was super fresh and flavorful....an exceptionally well made pizza!