Pie In the Sky Pizza

The customer service was good. Everyone was friendly. I ordered the Mac and cheese balls with ranch and the marinara. Much to my surprise, the Mac and cheese balls AND the marinara were really bland. I went home and added a little garlic salt and pepper, and it still wasn't the best. I found myself drowning the Mac and cheese balls in the ranch sauce to get through it. The ranch is really tasty and unfortunately was the best part of the meal. Maybe the pizza and the other menu options are good, but I am not rushing to go back and try this place.

Pizza, pizza, pizza, pizza, pizza... gonna get me some pizza. I've had take-out from the gas station a few times but the last time I ate here was during the plandemic and here was about a mile up the road across the hall from the license plate agency downtown before the markdale got renovated.anyway, tonight we pulled up on a little retro pizza joint that used to be my drycleaners and it looks like there's not nearly enough parking until you actually get to the parking and it goes off to the right for about 50 spaces which begs the question of what was here before the fresh asphalt and motion sensing LED lighting..? ¿nature?so tonight we're sitting outside in the warm, dry evening air enjoying a medium sized pie with pepperonis, sausages, onions, and green pepper and fountain beverages. a larger pizza would be more cost effective but lately pizza for breakfast leaves me sluggish all day :-( pizza comes out soon enough and we make our way around the platter as the daylight fades to twilight then to dusk and we're still sitting and smiling and holding hands...

We did takeout, so I can't speak to the inside!Honestly, pretty good! Ordered garlic bread (just to see), pastrami sub, and a small Detroit style pizza.The order took a little while, but it gave me a chance to swing by the the downtown bookstore so... not mad at it! The food was ready when we pulled up so that was solid. The garlic bread is a little salty, but I did eat probably more than a normal person should... so if you eat a normal amount you might not notice that.The sub was still extremely hot when we got home so massive kudos on the packaging for that. My husband liked his sandwich and didn't add any more commentary... he ate it all so I imagine that's a nice compliment.The Detroit style pizza is good. The sauce is quite sweet, but I don't mind that so it worked out for me. It's four slides, but as expected is pretty thick. So on top of the garlic bread I didn't eat all of the pizza in one sitting. Saving some for later!

Just a heads up - this pizza spot is in a gas station! We were unaware when we placed the order so we were a bit shocked when we pulled up. The pizza was very good though! Great flavors and interesting pizzas. They also told us it would be a 45 minute wait but they were done in 15 minutes. I would still recommend this spot, but just want to give a heads up. I do think they might be getting a new location at some point, but I am not sure the details.

Love that Pie in the Sky found a new permanent home! And absolutely love what they did with - wait for it... an old dry cleaners place!I love being able to order on ChowNow & it be ready when I arrive. I was told they have their own app coming soon, so I'm excited about that! Their single slices or regular sized pizzas always turn out great! My favorite order is ground beef & mushroom, thin crust. You can do make your own or they have specialized pizzas. Also, you can get salads & subs, here. Prices are reasonable. Friendly employees.

Went in for my first visit. Sat at the counter to speak to someone. There were 4 people (3 just standing around, one at the register) there and not a single person made eye contact or said hello, welcome or can I help you. One of the 4 was in shorts and a hoodie drinking a beer. Two of the employees interacted with him as if he was the manager. Maybe. A middle age lady with a script neck tattoo passed by me. From 5 feet she smelled like she had just smoked a pack of Marlboros. She needed a shower and a clean shirt. I don't want someone like that making my food. I left. I really wanted to try their pizza. There were just too many sanitary issues for me.

It should not take over 1 hour to make a pizza. Their excuse? We placed the order at the wrong counter.There is a dine-in register, and a take-out register.Now, there is no signage saying so.I guess you're just "supposed to know".Either way, even if I was dining in I wouldn't want to wait 1 hour for pizza.I could go to Epic Chophouse and get a top of the line steak dinner, and it would take less time.Sad.

We went for Thursday phillies and ordered the All the Way! It was freaking delicious!!!! I know it wasn't "traditional" with the black olives but that gave it the extra saltiness I like. I didn't add a thing! Enough cheese, lots of meat and just all around dang amazing!Alright planning out next Thursday...

Food is very average, not terrible. More disappointing was service. My wife ordered lasagna and when everyone else's food came, hers did not. After 10 minutes of waiting, we had to approach to counter and ask. It was then when no one apologized or admitted that the food had never been placed and we watched them prepare the food. Another 15 minutes later and the food came out with no apology or acknowledgment that everyone else was done eating. Expected a "sorry about the wait" but never heard a word. Not the worst place we've been but will not return if ever in the area.

Place is a joke, I ordered a Chicken Parm Stromboli and the chicken wasn't even real, it was frozen chicken nuggets put in dough with mozzarella cheese, where is the sauce? I should've known the type of place it was when the woman behind the counter literally handed me my box outside the door. Definitely shouldn't advertise something you do not know how to make. I am from NY and this was not anything described as Chicken Parm Stromboli, I threw away the food it was so disgusting. Get some tips from Hawthornes up the road on how to make decent Stromboli. If Hawthornes was open during lunch I would've went there, Id rather starve than spend my hard earned money here again. My experience moving here from NY is your standards are very low.