Johnny Tomatoes

Outstanding customer service and great pizza local, 5 out of 5 stars. The resturant is comfortable and clean inside.

First time back since they expanded the joint and was impressed with the new layout; more importantly the food was great, had the chicken balsamico sandwich and it was so big I took 1/2 home for lunch the next day, the wife had the chicken parmigiana sandwich and same story, great food and surplus was lunch for the next day.....Give them a try if you are in the area, you will be glad you did

Always delicious and the best....by far, in Indian Trail! Pizza is great...sides are good. Subs have the northern flair...great choice in this area!!!

Great Sicilian pie. Haven't had a Sicilian pie this good since leaving NY. Definitely my Ney go to place for pizza.

We went here on a whim to try something other than Pizza Hut. The pizza was good and the garlic knots too. The service well that left a lot to be desired. They take your order at the register and bring your food to the table. That's it for service. I was disappointed that they pass the surcharges of credit cards on to the customer. This is probably why we won't come back. Not the food but passing fees to your customers.

Our first time here and we liked it a lot. We shared an antipasto salad with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing. The sell pizza by the slice as well as whole pizza and a variety of other items. They will add condiments to the pizza slices. Everything was great and the staff is Uber friendly.

The food wasn't worth it, coming all the way from Charlotte.The salad itself was cut up into almost two smaller pieces. It was hard to fork all of it. The cheese pizza was decent, nothing to rave about or drive all the way for.

Johnny needs to get back behind the counter and start making these pizza's like they use too roughly a month ago. Not sure what changed but it's different and not for the better.

Our most recent experience at Johnny Tomaties left me with mixed feelings. I specifically asked not to over bake our pizza, but unfortunately it was over baked . The flavors are there but the execution fell short. We did add to our order a Meatball roll which was absolutely delicious and baked to perfection. We also indulged in Buffalo Chicken Calzone that every bite was enjoyed. Staff has always been pleasant and friendly. I won't walk away saying I'll never go back and hopefully Johnny will have a chance to redeem himself.

Pizza was amazing vodka pie and regularly cheese with spicy sauce on it nice thin crust definitely would recommend Johnny tomatoes