Italian Garden Restaurant

Family gathering consisting of four adults and three kids for lunch. There is nothing fancy about this place, but everyone was friendly, and the service was outstanding. I ordered the senior spaghetti and meatballs. It was outstanding with just the right serving size for my 70-year-old appetite. My wife had the chicken sub plate and said her was good. The children all had the chicken alfredo from the children's menu. Two of the adults split a pizza and neither thought it was that good. The bill for everything which included 7 drinks was $61.60, which I thought was very reasonable. This appears to be a local hangout as everyone knew each other. I recommend this place for a good, reasonably priced lunch. My wife and I will be back.

New to the area. Literally live not even a mile from this place. Friends have recommended this place because it's alway busy. On the way home from work. Starving so I decided to call in my order. As I pulled up, it was busy yet very casual. Family friendly. I ordered a spaghetti with meatballs to go. Added a salad and a coke. Now, I don't think I had a back spaghetti dish. And it's my comfort food.But I didn't even know you can make spaghetti soo bland, nothing to the sauce. Nor meatballs. I was looking for cheese, or pepper flakes. I mean something/anything. But my stuffs are still in boxes. Guess I won't be ordering spaghetti from there. And try another dish.

Wow. This restaurant is stuck in time. While passing through York we stumbled across this place and made an effort to stop in when we had a chance. I am glad we did. I had the chicken parm sub and my wife had a small cheese pizza. The service was very friendly and was quite busy when we arrived. The menu is very reasonable. The prices for the portions are acceptable and the food was very nice. I would certainly stop by again as this is the best value I have seen coming from a much larger city. Kudos to the staff, the kitchen, and the owner. It's always good to see a restaurant that puts the customers first. NCFOODGUY Robert

Food was barely passable. Had the Souvlaki, but a Greek didn't make this! The price for the portion was the worst part. The service was also lacking. They wouldn't refill our drinks. The inside style is old dive bar feel. Not the good kind..

My first visit to Italian garden. I was not impressed. The waitress never asked if I would like a refill. Yuck

Baked spaghetti and pizza is sooo good! Only thing I wish about the food is the salads come with cheese!

They do pretty good... not crazy expensive.. idk why the bad reviews... but I order something simple anyway, usually... so it's a firm 5 stars for me... service seems up to par also!

Consistently excellent food and service! The pizza is always cooked to perfection and the wait staff is always friendly and outgoing. Highly recommended! Two thumbs WAY up.

Waitress came and told us that there would be a 20% tip on a part of 8 or more because of "stiffing". When asked if that would be the case of separating the bill, she told us 20% would be added to each bill, and then accused us of stiffing her from a later time. We have always tipped well with each of the other waitresses. This waitress has always given us problems, she will come take our order and never come back to our table to refill our drinks or check on us. I've always tried to tip every waitress, but if you don't come and check on us refill our drinks, then I will not tip you. But as of today, we will not be returning. I will NOT recommend this establishment to anyone!

The atmosphere is a bit outdated but the food is always great! We have been eating here for about 13 years. I have tried many different items on the menu and my only complaint is I wish the side salads had something besides lettuce and a slice of tomato. I've always had great service from the staff. Highly recommend!