Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Dessert Pizza
Special Pizza
the front of the restaurant
the front of the restaurant
Turkey Wrap with a side of Pasta Salad - YUM!!!
outside, pizza
Made to order!!!!
Turkey Wrap with Pasta Salad
a slice of pepperoni pizza
Great buffet!
Pepperoni and Ham Calzone
Ziti with Marinara
Side salad with yummy honey mustard
Calzone
Chef Salad
Blackened Chicken Pasta
Aven S.
Feb 14, 2024
I came in at 6:20 on a Wednesday. The restaurant was pretty empty so I was expecting a pretty quick meal. I remember in the past the hickory location had a buffet option the Newton one I came to did not. I got mozzarella sticks and a steak and cheese pizza. Value for price is pretty good but the taste is lackingIt might just be the type of pizza I ordered but I love Philly cheesesteaks, the sauce doesn't really have any flavor and neither does the cheese. I got a ranch to dip it in and their ranch is the classic steakhouse homemade ranch that is so good. The mozzarella sticks were also not very flavorful. Also the meal took a while to come out, which I understand but I was hoping my cheese sticks would come out first. If I were to come back I'd order something else or go of the hickory location for the buffet
Read MoreMark B.
Dec 30, 2023
We grabbed a few pies to bring home. Solid pizza. The thin crust is cracker thin with crunchy crust. The sauce is on the sweeter side. For my taste, I'd like it a little less sweet and more crispy than crunchy, but definitely a solid pie. You won't be disappointed.
Read MoreThomas E.
Apr 12, 2023
Great food. Asleyas taste fresh and hot. Attentive servers makes this please even better. The restaurant itself is clean and tidy. Reminds you of and older pizza parlor
Read MoreAmanda M.
Dec 5, 2020
Got delivery both times and both times were really good! Wings were good salad was great Stromboli was to die for (get extra marinara on the side :))
Read MoreBrian N.
Jun 9, 2024
Saturday dinner 5:30pm, 6/9/24: First time patron and decided to try it based on the strong reviews.Took my MIL to get pizza and we like the atmosphere as we were seated. Quick service after ordering the Special pizza with a beer and white wine.I think this was likely our favorite restaurant pizza ever! That's saying a lot but it was well deserved. The crust was perfect, the sauce slightly sweet and the ingredients delicious! As we finished our meal we noticed the place was nearly full, so others must feel the same. Definitely will come back to try their pastas.Highly recommend
Read MoreKasey K.
Oct 7, 2023
There food has always been good but I do wish that they would bring back there pizza buffet which was one of my favorite things about the place but they have stopped it sadly there service has always been good and they've always been friendly.
Read MoreKathy O.
Oct 25, 2023
Awesome service from a waitress that has been with Neil since place in opened since the 80's. Great place, great food, great service. Always feel at home.
Read MoreLaura D.
Aug 29, 2023
The food here is amazing! They have the best cauliflower crust and all the toppings are fresh and delicious! The staff is very friendly!
Read MoreBeverly L.
Jul 4, 2023
Now Geppeto's has delicious food anytime I want a salad or some lasagna or anything form Geppeto's I like
Read MoreMadilyn W.
Jun 13, 2023
As for cleanliness it is ok.... food is good, i'm a sucker for desert pizza, and personally i think there's is the best.
Read More