Cara’s Cookie Company

My favorite food group is dessert, so naturally when I walked into Gibson Mill Market and the first vendor I saw was Cara's Cookie Company, I was absolutely delighted! It's very simple to order - they have everything they offer on display and when you make your choices they pull fresh cookies from the back. This is also the only place I've ever seen a cookie push pop and I LOVE this creative idea! I chose the coffee toffee, chocolate chip, and snickerdoodle cookies along with a cookie push pop. Firstly the cookies are massive. I'm a person who can eat an entire cookie in one sitting but I would think for most people they could eat on one for days. They also have an over abundance of toppings and I love this so much. There wasn't a lack of chocolate chips or toffee on the cookies. These cookies are also super heavy so you know they're packed with flavor. If you're visiting Gibson Mill Market I highly recommend stopping at Cara's Cookie Company for dessert after your meal or a treat to take home!

Very sweet service and delicious dessert cookies! The cookies are very large and perfect for sharing! We went by today to grab a Coffee-Toffee cookie and it was amazing! So many warm flavors wrapped up in one big cookie. It was just what we needed! The staff at the shop was very kind and welcoming and we can't wait to go back! Such a cute place and I look forward to trying other flavors next time!!!

I came here to buy cookies for my daughter's birthday. It sounded like a good alternative to the usual birthday cake. I am pleased with the decision. Everyone liked their cookie. The cookie shop is located within the Gibson Mill Market(food court). The entire area has been renovated so everything is new and clean. They had about a dozen different flavors to choose from. I selected a double chocolate chip cookie for myself. It was delicious. It was massive and heavy. I also got some Oreo cookie flavor, smores, salted caramel pretzel, and a strawberry chocolate drizzle. All were delicious. They came individually wrapped and were readily available.

Cute food stall in the new Gibson Mill Market. The cookies are HUGE. The cashier said they are almost half a pound each. I got the chocolate chip cookie and it was amazing!! I thought they were going to be more like scones when I saw them but they weren't at all. It was such a moist cookie! It was a little underbaked which is how I like them. There were soooo many chocolate chips inside and on top. I will definitely come back to try their other flavors!

Huge cookies! A little pricey even though it is a huge cookie. Would love to try all the flavors as they had severalto choose from.

So we got 2 cookies.Mind you at $5 each!-Salted pretzel chocolate chip, great cookie until you got to the middle. Raw cookie dough in the middle, raw. Again great cookie until you hit the center.-Chocolate chip, very good. No complaints.Try it at least once.

Exactly what I was looking for..the cookies were delicious and reasonably priced.. I also love the girls that are working here with

I just got married and I am so happy we worked with this company to make our wedding cake! It tasted absolutely amazing and it looked fantastic! We also ordered their 4 oz cookies and the guests loved them! The service is great! They helped us get what me and my husband have always dreamed about!

These Cookies are not very good at all. Not sure if we came on a bad night, but we were hanging out with friends downstairs at the brewery and had got a couple Pizza's upstairs and noticed the cookie company near by. So before we left for the night. About 7:00 we stopped by to grab a few cookies. Right away we noticed what seemed to be a High School girl sitting on the back counter on her phone most of the time we were standing there deciding on what we wanted. She finally jumped down and took our order. We got 2 Chocolate Chip and a s'mores, and a Lemmon Blueberry. The Chocolate Chip was just a clump of Cookie Dough with half a bag of chocolate chips packed in it. All of the cookies were very dense and Scone like. It tasted pretty flavorless. I ended up only eating half of my 2 cookies. They were very overpriced as well. We spent $21 on a great pizza plus 2 drinks and it cost us more than that for 4 mediocre cookies. The shop is very cute and decorated and displayed nicely but I really think they need to change the recipe on these.

These cookies are simply not good and overpriced. I asked the employee if the cookies are fresh and she said no, they were baked the day before. All 5 people with me tried the cookie and agreed it tasted very bad and had a horrible texture (it was really hard). Only giving 1 star because the center was *decent* when I heated up in the microwave. You're much better off going to Crumbl or Cookie Co.