Brooklyn South Pizzeria
Brooklyn South Pizzeria
Fettuccini Alfredo
Calzone
Cannoli
Nonna's Pizza
NY Cheese Pie
Fresh Eggplant Parmigiana
a variety of food items
Kids Cheese Ravioli
a variety of pizzas
a bucket full of beer bottles
a salad in a bowl
Order counter
a variety of pizzas
Baked Ziti
Twains Amber Ale
New York Style half cheese and half pepporoni
Pepperoni pinwheels and Nona slice of pizza
The New York Original
Pepperoni - The New York Original Really good.
South Brooklyn
Nonna pizza
Garlic knots
food, pasta dish, pasta
food, pizza
Meesh G.
Dec 29, 2024
We have ordered from Brooklyn South since it was established in 1998 and used to be on the other side of the road by Harris Teeter. It's the best New York style pizza in the area. With that being said, it is no where close to having a slice of pizza in NYC, but it's the closest you will get to one from this area. The sauce has a little sweetness to it, and you can taste all those spices in it. They put a good amount of cheese, and the dough has the right amount of crunch. We tried the pinwheels for the first time. The flavor was nice as you can really taste the pepperoni, but it was unfortunately overcooked.
Read More
Rachel M.
Nov 30, 2024
We love coming here with our family! The room in the back is perfect for party occasions! All the food is delicious! I like everything I try, this time I got the Buffalo chicken pizza and cheese bread! You can't go wrong with anything! They are very helpful there getting us everything we need!
Read More
Massiel G.
May 18, 2024
We had a Sicilian and a couple of regular slices. Loved it! We will def be back! Cute spot too. Friendly service.
Read More
Heather G.
Oct 22, 2024
Great local pizza place. Self service ordering makes it a quick and easy family dining experience. Garlic knots and NY style pizza slice do not disappoint.
Read More
Jacob B.
Oct 13, 2024
This restaurant deserves a 5 star rating. They are expensive but you get what you pay for. Been coming here for years and it is hands down the best pizza in this area
Read More
Noah M.
Apr 16, 2024
Walked in to get a togo New York style pizza. Just cheese. Girls at the counter were very nice and helpful. When you walk in you can tell it's a New York style place in the south. Pizza was fantastic! Above average for sure. Foldable and crust was crisp to perfection. Very pleased with the outcome. Great job!
Read More
Suzanne S.
Jun 28, 2022
Stopped in for lunch on the recommendation of some Facebook group who claimed they have awesome garlic knots and NY style pizza. So glad I did! The person who took my order was so incredibly nice and helpful! She gave me recommendations, talked to me about real estate and even brought me a go box without asking. Sweet!This is one of those establishments where you order at the counter and go sit down with a "neighborhood" in NYC as your number. They'll bring out the food to you.I didn't feel like getting garlic knots AND pizza, so I opted for the knots and chicken parm on the recommendation of my server. The garlic knots were indeed excellent, but a bit dry. I love the knots that have the garlic butter poured on them. These are served with a cup of marinara that was yummy. The chicken parm was ok. The chicken tenders were huge and the portion was enormous. It truly was enough for 3 meals, especially when you get the knots, too. I'd definitely try something different next time.The cool thing about this restaurant is the sheer number of pizzas and pies you can get by the slice. When I go back, and I will be back, I'm getting one of those slices.The Good* The Service was so kind and helpful* Tons of room in the dining room* Garlic knotsThe Bad* The bathroom wasn't my favoriteBottom line: They are known for their pizza. Try that!
Read More
Dennis B.
Sep 2, 2024
Brooklyn South is a staple for our family. Has been for all of their 25 years. They've been pleasantly consistent the entire time - good food at an affordable price with excellent service.Yesterday, they topped themselves by doing something I've seen nowhere else - offering to use their pizza cutter to cut two slices of the kids' pizza. Usually, we have to wrestle with that task ourselves while the kids fidget restlessly. Not this time!A little extra effort that went a long way for a more enjoyable family dining experience.Well done, Brooklyn South!
Read More
sean c.
Oct 4, 2024
Prices online will not be honored. Cost of a stuffed pizza was $25.95 but the price when I went to pay they charged $31.95 a full $6.00. On their website there was not even a price listed. Spoke to the owner and she said they would not honor the price nor do they post their priced online so they can change them. Very dishonest.
Read More
Jack M.
Mar 8, 2024
anybody that gives this place less than a 5 star review should be vaporized immediately.None shall prevail against the Kingdom of Brooklyn South.A community staple for over a decade.If you don't like it you are a heretic undeserving of the original New York flop.
Read More
