Garlic pizza with pepperoni and artichoke
Menu as of 5/19/2022. Price hasn't changed since 2014!
Cheeseburger pizza
Meatlover's with added jalapeños.
Regular Hawaiian with grilled chicken added.
Cary's Pizza
Chicken Fajita Pizza
The Vintage Room
Dining room
Cary's Margherita Pizza
The Sports Room
The Kitchen
Love notes from fans
Typical dining room at Carys
Kitchen view
Reading shelf
Tomato Garlic Supreme Pizza
Historic registry sign
The Garden Room
Separate dining rooms
Cary's Pizza Menu (1 of 3)
Cary's Pizza Menu (3 of 3)
Super cute little historic house redone for a resturant
Separate dining room
Kelly C.
Jun 15, 2024
What a delightful experience! After an impromptu drive from No Phoenix, we ended up in Wickenburg. We hadn't eaten dinner and found Carys Pizza on Yelp. What a great find. We had the Tomato Gatlic Supreme pizza. Thin, crispy crust, flavorful tomatoes, and excellent sauce. Cary was at the front when we arrived, cooked our pizza and served it. Great guy! There was a young lady there who was also super friendly. The restaurant building is a converted charming house. Wonderful experience!
Read MoreLinda D.
Apr 11, 2024
Always a delicious meal, super crust and fresh toppings. Worth the wait, truly the best pizza in Wickenburg
Read MorePeggy G.
Feb 20, 2024
Wow! Winner! Thanks, Yelpers, for leading us here. Hubs and I each ordered 10" pies: robust and full of toppings. meatlover + jalapeños for him, Hawaiian + grilled chicken for me. Pix tell the story. Next time, I'll probably order 6-1/2". Would be plenty of food for my usual appetite.
Read MoreC C.
Feb 21, 2024
Pizza taste and texture of cracker. I ordered double the pepperoni and it had less than a normal pizza ordered elsewhere.
Read MoreDennis P.
Nov 19, 2023
We called in for a pizza pick up. The pizza was ready when they said it would be. Very busy little place. I loved the crust nice and airy and great flavor. The toppings were fresh and the sauce was tasty. Very friendly staff.
Read MoreSimon E.
Jan 20, 2023
Don't be fooled by the hours on Yelp. Cary's is not open for lunch. At least not today (Friday 20th Jan) - and watch the roadworks; lots of street closures.
Read MoreMark D.
Jun 6, 2023
Our first time visiting Cary's and we were not disappointed! Parking is a bit rough, but the restaurant is nicely decorated with several separate rooms in different decors - cozy and private, should you choose. Cary greeted us and we sat in the main area. The menu has a good selection, and we found everything we were looking for. The pizza was amazing! The crust and texture are very European - I don't know how he does it!
Read MoreMo C.
Sep 9, 2023
Great pizza! Cary is awesome.a great asset in Wickenburg.. great job to all thanks for everything.
Read MoreRobert M.
Dec 1, 2022
Can't review the food because we sat for 15 minutes in a restaurant with only 3 tables of people. No one took our order. No one acknowledged us. Nothing. This was a Thursday at 530.
Read MoreBob B.
Mar 27, 2024
This is a one man show. Don't be in a hurry. The pizza was pretty good but we both had bad indigestion all night afterwards. We might return for a second try.
Read More