carly's Rolling Bay Cafe

COVID times review:When we visited the coffe shop WA already reopen business, so masks are not mandatory anymore BUT as a matter of caution this place requires customers to mask up and IT'S OK. We all are taking care of each other.I didn't see the signs that says "ONE CUSTOMER AT A TIME" oops! But then other customer did the same thing, and I felt better. So yeah, because the space is quite small, waiting line is outside the shop. The coffee was great, as well as the pastries (pan au chocolat, croissants, apple muffins and chocolate chip cookie) I'd say that it's worth to wait if you see a wait line, you'll get your order in a pretty decent time. Also while you wait you can take a look to the plants and flowers from the next door shop.I saw on their menu they also have egg sandwiches I may go back to try them ;)

The morning bun! They have one of the best morning buns! Flakey texture on the outside and almost doughy on the inside on some parts, such a great combo. The place has outdoor seating and man, it was super cold but a nice warm Cuban sandwich helped us beat the cold, on our way to our hike! Definitely a nice stop before continuing the day!

This is for a quick detour for a grande iced mocha heading back towards Bremerton. (6/16/18).I had stopped in at the adjacent Bay Feed and Hay Nursery the previous Saturday.Both places were cool to checkout...both cool interesting and cool standoffish. Clearly I'm not a local resident, both individuals at this indie cafe were servicable but didn't exude any welcoming warmth. Three stars.The extra star was due to receiving an end product mocha that was on point...not cloying, could taste the balance with smooth finish. They use Grounds for Change beans.Cafe featured Farm Kitchen products and other baked goods. There's only outdoor seating. Reminded me of Cafe Bambino in Seattle. Started a stamp card. Four starts total.The stop was long enough to make that assessment of a decent iced mocha, plus make a cell phone call before hitting the road again.

Poor customer service. I wanted a coffee on my birthday today (Sun Nov 1 at 10:15am) and found this place along our route. I masked up and walked up to where the signs directed me and opened the door. The barista immediately said: I'm going to need you to please wait outside. It was very off putting so we left!If you want guests to wait outside please put signs up so we know this ahead of time. We can't read minds.Next time please ASK your customer to wait outside instead of ordering them to do something and they might stick around and order a bevvie.

This is the closest coffee shop in the neighborhood. They do a consistently good job on their espresso drinks. Their baked treats, sandwiches and other drinks are good as well. They have very little space inside. However, they have a wonderful, covered seating area outdoors over looking the neighborhood nursery. So, it's a great place to hang out and and enjoy the passing of the seasons. The owners are dedicated to the Rollingbay neighborhood, and contribute mightily to the community. As other reviewers notice, they do struggle sometimes with the warm and cheerful part of the business. Perhaps some upbeat music?

I love this place! I've moved away from Rolling Bay but I still go out of my way to get coffee here. The coffee drinks are top-notch, the staff are really nice and the breakfast sandwiches are delicious.The little outdoor seating adjacent to the nursery is a nice "secret spot" to hang out as well.They are being very conscientious about Covid and that's good - right? So be patient, follow the rules and enjoy!

I remember the coffee being good; but not high enough quality to balance out the unfriendliness of the staff. I had a better time getting coffee from the Italian restaurant across the street.It's tough to have a good morning when I'm made to feel that my presence is a burden. An improved hello upon entry and less "you can wait outside in January, your drink will be placed on the table at the back door".Stick to the Winslow coffee shops; or look into an espresso from a nearby restaurant before going here.

Carly's changed ownership last year, but all the great service and food has continued. Yay! This is still my go-to local spot for a pastry and especially their cafe miel - sweetened with honey. My son gets either a kids hot chocolate (with whipped cream and sprinkles) or a vanilla steamer. He gives thumbs up to both.

Where did all the chickens go? The Bay Hay Rooster signage & 'all are welcome' warmth, that existed for decades has been removed from our local neighborhood cafe. Coffee and pastries are still locally sourced, thankfully.

This is my favorite little gem on the island. Great coffee, great service, great food!!