Brooklyn Bros. Pizzeria

So for the last two years we have walked past Brooklynn Bros restaurant and always said I bet it's nice in there. Well It Is !! lol. Yes finally just before I started my diet we decided to give it a try now I have to wait 20 weeks to go again boo hoo. This is genuine New York time pizza served fresh to your table in whole pizzas or slices so you can sample many without breaking the bank. Slices are about $4.00 each we tried three and they do not disappoint. Super crisp base wit fresh mozzarella they are to die for. We will be back over and over I just have to wait 19 weeks

Service was great, ladies were really nice and way very helpful answering questions. We went during the day so there were not too many people, and the seating outside is nice. Ambiance is pretty quiet throughout the day, but busier throughout the night. The Sicilian pepperoni is so good and very thin, the flavor is very good too. Onto the calzone, the calzone was very airy not very thick. The pizza dough was very good but did not have much protein even though I got double chicken. Still was pretty good but wish it was loaded with chicken rather than having one or two small bites.

I've lived in Mill Creek for 4 years and didn't know this place existed. Used Yelp to find a new pizza spot, and some common sense to filter the reviews and decided this was a good spot to order from. Got a pizza and Caesar salad and were very impressed. That was about a month or so ago - but a couple weeks ago my wife and I went to NYC and I was reminded about how you could just grab a good slice on the go and mentally noted I needed to stop in at Brooklyn Bros when I got home. Today was the day, it's just me and my son for dinner so we swung in and grabbed some slices and breadsticks - the staff were amazing and kind and ready to assist. Their restaurant is tucked into Mill Creek Town Center in such as way I had literally driven past it for 4 years without any idea it was there. The slices are NYC quality and hands down a go-to spot for the future. Love how close they are - which is perfect because they've been added to the weekly rotation.

Updated review: Quality is still the same and it's decent. However, when ordering a Large 18" cheese at the Mill Creek location it's smaller and not good since the large pizza is $25 here. You don't get what you pay for.

Great staff, fantastic pizza.They allowed us to bring in our own homemade cake for my nephew's birthday celebration.Love that they have a full bar.

The pizza rivals any I've had anywhere. You can get whole pizzas or slices of several different varieties. There's also salads and sides on the menu. Good selection of cold beers.Service is spot on. Fun, casual atmosphere. 'I'll be back'

Abruptly was hung up on by the immature girl after we canceled our order. This was not a call back to cancel. This was one phone call. If you don't want to work in hospitality, than don't. I just hope the person that writes your checks is ok having you shit all over their business.

Best NY pizza I have found so far in this area. I am excited to go back. I liked the relaxed environment and kind servers. This place does get a lot of take out orders.

Not impressed, too expensive, the Hudson was bland and cold, the white was just okay and NOT woodfire like reviews are saying, we won't be back.

I grew up in NJ. This is the most authentic East Coast pizza in the entire Puget Sound area. Period! Save room for the Cannolis! YUM!!!