Big Mario's Northlake Tavern

10/13/23 - I will say this is one of the more bizarre food experiences I've had but I'll still give it 3 stars for the overall review. I called and ordered the Logger Silician (https://www.instagram.com/p/CyEbzBRMGk3/) as a part of The Stranger's pizza week. I was told it would be about a 45 minute which was no issue. I showed up about 1 hour later, paid for my pie and left. I noticed that when I got back to the car, the pizza was completely wrong. I went back in and they confirmed that I was given a regular (new york style) Macho Man. The employees stated that they had two orders for Max - mine and one via doordash (where the person ordered the macho man) and accidentally mixed them up. They also said they were out of the dough for sicilian style and forgot to tell me on the phone. I was told I could keep the macho man free and that they'd remake me a Logger (new york style) - free of charge. After waiting 15 minutes, I was asked to give back the macho man pie, since apparently the doordash driver was coming back to pick it up. Kind of odd to ask for it back I thought, but I did return it and the employee gave me a free pepperoni pizza instead. After another 10-15 minutes I had my Logger. I went home and tried both pizzas - the Logger was very good and the pepperoni was dry - not sure if it was because it had been sitting out above their oven for awhile, but I still appreciate the gesture from them. Overall I'd probably pass on eating here again but we'll see. I think the communication and order accuracy needs to improve first. Cool location though.

Big Mario's is off to a strong start since they just opened. We ordered two 14" pizzas, and trust me, they're generous in size. Between the Coppa Cabana and Midnight Rambler pizzas, the Rambler stood out with its gorgonzola flavor. The caesar salad was good, especially with the ample dressing. They've got dine-in, take-out, and even a bar. Our server was friendly, though he seemed a bit swamped. Parking's available, and while it can get loud, the vibe is fun.

Disappointed sums it up. Should have been expected after the high mark that The Northlake Tavern set. The pies are nothing like they used to be (not surprised) and the Horsey cartoons and most UW sports decor are seemingly gone. Pizza was ok but nothing special. The service was good. Bartender gladly helped us swap out the empty napkin and parmesan containers when asked.Much like many classic Seattle joints, this one has been "cleansed" of its charm and what it was known for. Don't need to go back.

Delicious pizza, reasonably priced pitchers, and good music. We had a fantastic time.++Kid-friendly before 9 PM. Our toddler had a blast.

So happy to have Big Mario's here!First, I have to say I am surprised to see people saying they missed the pizza from Northlake Tavern... those old frozen pie crusts made me so sad! I was thrilled to see big Mario's taking over here with some real and fresh dough and true NY style pizzas.As a born and raised New Yorker, true NY pizza is hard to find out here! They do a great job, with a nice thin crispy crust and appropriate amount of toppings. You can't go wrong with a classic pepperoni, but they do have a lot to choose from and it's all good. This place is also so much more fun than Northlake! There is trivia, drag, dancing... nothing like the old sleepy location. If you don't want to sit down for a slice, you can always grab one from their to-go window for a quick dinner. The only thing that could make them better is if they made some NY style wings to go with these NY style slices

Went in at 4:45 and waited 15 minutes for a wait person to drop a sign on our table stating "order at counter after 5PM"; pretty weak, they were far from crowded, just utterly unenthused.The place looks basically the same as before, less the Horsey artwork.Pizzas are thin and floppy. I rolled slices into hot-pocket burritos. I can't think of any other pizza where this would work.It's pizza shaped food. They have beer. Plenty of seating.

i took my nephew to Big Mario's to see how the Northlake Tav replacement was doing as reviews have been mixed. We had been to the Tav 2 days before it closed (8 hour wait.) We had the Harlem Classic Sicillian-style square pizza. We both thought it was excellent! I strongly recommend it. I also suggest you go as early as possible. We arrived about 5:30, parked right in front and there were just a couple people already there. I thought the music was great (60s and 70s) and it wasn't too loud as some of the complaints I read. It did get louder later but nowhere near as loud as the Northlake Tav was. The guy behind the bar described as a gray-bearded guy was also criticized in reviews was nice to us. His name is Nathan. Go enjoy a pizza!

Pizza was good but the service is what inspired the low star review. Walked in over an hour before closing and ordered a few salads and a pizza. Pizza did not come out for almost 45 minutes (leaving us little time to eat) and our server was extremely rude. Disappointing experience :(

First time in 30 years I walked into this establishment and not a soul was inside. I guess I shouldn't even compare it to Northlake Tavern Pizza. Although I spent $37 for the "Northlake Combo", it wasn't a third of what you used to get for $45. Add in the $7.50 tap Manny's Pale Ales, and the $11 salad greens thrown in a bowl with some olives and feta cheese that was called a "Greek" salad for the complete disappointment. Never mind that I got a contact high from Jamil and the gal that were supposed to be working there that were out in front of Voula's smoking pot when I parked so much that I was overwhelmed when I got out of my car 50 feet away from them. Then Jamil proceeded to be loud and obnoxious in his state of inebriation talking about how he was going to give his coworkers a knuckle sandwich when they finally got to work 15 minutes late for their shift. (I did let them know privately what he was saying about them in front of the whole restaurant.) I have to say my wife was uncomfortable when presented with the "All Gender" restroom sign and she had to use the bathroom next to 3 urinals. No wonder the place was empty.

Pizza's great and usually have a great atmosphere, but tonight was off with the Grey bearded bartender/ employee as I ordered a couple pizzas off the specials board, and he kept getting more confused and more hostile as if he didn't understand what I was talking about, which is clearly stated on the board on the wall and overcharge us. Luckily, the manager I believe (amazingly in shorts and crop top) listened, acknowledged, and made sure we got the correct bill.