Big Mario's Pizza

I've been here many times (mostly after clubbing in cap lol) and it always hits the spot. Came here w/my bf in December most recently. He's from NY and agrees this is the closest to NY pizza in Seattle he's tried. I love the curled up peps, large slice, and crust! It's nice when you don't want a whole pie but need to fulfill your pizza craving.

Best pizza we've had in years! This is a new favorite spot we will frequent! Recommended by our Real Estate Agent. Sooo good and the service is great!!

Finally found a great pizza spot on the West coast! The food and the service was awesome!

Pizza is so goood!!!!! Had a good time, fun music and good food. It was a good environment for 11pm pizza.

Ugh 0 if I could. I don't know how this place stays open. Toppings and cheese have been less and less over time and last time I was here they totally forgot about my order. Skip this place. Sucks. Literally anywhere else is better.

The food is Amazing and the portion is very big would definitely recommend if your in the mood for delicious hot new York style pizza

If you love NY style pizza like I do, look no further! This is the best NY style pizza you're going to find in Seattle. I highly recommend the Pear Gorgonzola pizza, but the Williamsburg is also bomb! I'm glad I can get this pizza delivered to my house, but it definitely tastes best right out of the oven. The vibe in here is really cool, also!

The pizza here is bussin whether you're drunk or sober. I've been here at 3am after the club outingsI go here during the day after a gym seshYou can't go wrong with the pepperoni pizza. They generously top their slices with pepperoni and bake it to perfection where it is slightly crispy. I have to get a beer when I get pizza. I like mannys. Also get some ranch to go with your za.

Food - very good pizza by the slice or whole pizza. You can do take out or dine in if you're all 21+ at the booths by the bar. There are NA soda options as well as usual bar options. Service - the folks were very friendly and seemed to all know each other and all be pretty friendly with one another and many patrons. Ambiance - it's a small kind of dive bar space with pizza at the front. It's great for sitting down and chilling with some friends. I would definitely grab pizza from here again! This is probably some of the better NY style slice pizza in Cap Hill.

A new yorker here. I don't usually eat pizza often but many recommended this as the best NY pizza in Seattle. They got the crust right: crispy, light. Though there wasn't hardly enough cheese, it was the sauce that wasn't good. There was too much of a kick and not enough sweetness and due to the ratio of cheese to sauce, it tasted like spicy bread. Disappointed by this one.