Tony's Of NY Pizza Kitchen
Tony's Of NY Pizza Kitchen
Prosciutto & Mozzarella sandwich
Prosciutto and Mozzarella sub.
Prosciutto and Mozzarella sub.
Stars!
Interior Decor
Stuffed Meat Pie
NY Margherita by the slice
NY Pepperoni Slice
pepperoni slice folded
Prosciutto & Mozzarella sub
a view of the counter
Pizza Ovens
Rear Dining Room
a slice of pizza
Counter
Pizza Boxes
Pizza by the slice
Cheesesteak sub with just provolone
Ziti Pie Slice
Chef Salad
Garden Salad
Combo Pizza 19" thin crust
Entrance decorated for First-Year Anniversary!
Half Cheesesteak and half French fries
Linda K.
Jan 11, 2025
Ordered take out. Chicken parm sub, side of fries and a cannoli for dessert. The sub was a foot-long. It was huge. And it was delicious. There was four huge pieces of chicken on the sub. Covered in cheese and sauce. The fries were great, but when I've had them in the restaurant, they've been more crispy. The best part of the meal was dessert. The cannoli was excellent.
Read More
Tear S.
Jan 26, 2025
I recently visited Tony's of NY. It was on a late Saturday afternoon. I was looking for a good slice of pizza and looked to see what Yelp suggested. Tony's wasn't too far from my location, so I took the trip. I wasn't familiar with the neighborhood, but I could tell it was nicely kept & quiet. The restaurant itself was pretty standard. The inside was neat & clean, and the atmosphere was welcoming. The front counter had an attractive pizza showcase with all different kinds of pizza pies displayed. My eyes settled upon a meat lover's slice and a chicken mushroom Alfredo slice. The manager rung me up. He was very nice. My total came to about $12 for two slices and a soft drink. I decided to eat inside. While waiting, I went to the rest room. It was tidy and clean. If it were awful, I'm sure I'd remember that. The wait time for my pizza wasn't long at all (less than ten minutes). When the waitress came with my food, I was blown away by the sizes of the slices! They were huge! Definitely worth the price I paid. I sprinkled my parm and chili flakes on top and dived in. I should've waited a bit for everything to cool, because the cheese was so hot, that I burned the roof of my mouth. The meat lovers pizza was pretty good. It wasn't slam dunk amazing, but it was decent. I think extra sauce on top would've gave it a bit of that extra something that I desired. The star of the show was the chicken mushroom Alfredo slice! OMG! That pizza was SLAMMING! I've never had that kind before, and the flavors paired so well together. Don't think that the crust will get soggy. It was crispy the whole way through. I finished the meat lovers slice and ate half of the chicken/mushroom one. It was even tasty the next day, after popping it into the air fryer. This may be my new pizza shop to go to when I want a delicious pie. They had a veggie slice that looked pretty good. I'll try that one next time. All in all, good food, decent prices, good customer service, and big portions. Check them out!
Read More
John W.
Sep 25, 2024
Returned with a companion to enjoy some TONY. Love the NYC ambiance of the joint. Counter Service and expediting fine.We shared an appetizer of Eggplant Rollatini and each ordered the Italian Stallion cold cut sub. Food was on point. Subs were well prepared and delicious but coulda been packed with more meat and cheese. We shared a serving of Tiramisu for dessert. Will return soon.
Read More
Maggi R.
Dec 3, 2024
Congratulations on your first-year anniversary! We were delighted to be a part of your celebration and enjoy a 25% off saving on our meals. Thank you for being so generous to your loyal customers. My husband and I know a good Italian made sandwich when we have one. Your Prosciutto & Mozzarella sandwich transports us back to Italy every time. The bread is toasted on the outside - yet soft on the inside with thinly-sliced Italian prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, fresh basil, EVOO, and a drizzle of balsamic. It does not get much better than this. We also truly enjoy BYOB with no corkage fee. Grazie Sergio - wishing you many more years of success and great food!
Read More
Skyler P.
Jul 7, 2024
Was in town visiting family and was told I had to try this place. I was craving a good calzone so had to try on here. Delicious pizza dough and the calzone was really filled up! I went with a few meat options and then all the cheeses inside really did make this a great combination.
Read More
Cammi P.
Mar 24, 2024
Amazing place for takeout! The pizza was delicious and crispy and has the best tomato sauce. The mozzarella logs were amazing and a perfect blend of cheeses, however, they could've been warmer. Overall, an amazing dinner and I can't wait to keep eating here and explore all the delicious menu items.
Read More
Canuckfor H.
Nov 28, 2024
Great food and service. Always a friendly person to greet you. Take-out is easy and fast.
Read More
Robert L.
Dec 1, 2023
I saw this place being built, and was excited to try it, since there is really no good New York style pizza in the area. The other day I saw that it had opened and decided to try it tonight (opening weekend). The ordering process online via their website was flawless and despite it being exceptionally crowded with dine in and carry out customers was ready just minutes after arrival. There were many people working and everyone was warm and welcoming.Seating looked nice and very casual.The pizza had a thin, crisp crust (ordered it well done), sauce was fresh tasting, cheese was perfectly melted without too much grease. It is a good go to NY style pizza, and also has slices to go if you don't want the whole pie. Glad to have it in our neighborhood and excited to try their other foods. If they keep up this quality I think we have a new go to place! Keep up the good work!
Read More
Jeffrey S.
Nov 1, 2024
This place is the real deal. Great pizza and subs. Great service and friendly staff. Awesome neighborhood place.
Read More
Erica B.
Feb 26, 2025
Everything is great here! Pizza, subs and pasta are all done well. Love the penne vodka. Great for take out or dining in and family friendly. The staff are always so friendly and welcoming.
Read More
