Greek pizza
Italian Steak Sub
Seating area
interior, tacos
the counter and menu
outside
Seating area
Scan for their menu! Also sitting by the window is rough depending on the time of day. The sun blinds you with no escape.
Pizza full of grease.
interior
interior
Half pepperoni half cheese pizza. Onion fries & mozzarella sticks
Mostly craft beer tap list.
Italian steak sub
Main wall art
Dining area
Seating
The delicious fries
Large cheese pizza
Half of our small sausage pizza
Floor
Chicken wings
Current hours as of 06-02-2023
Hawaiian pizza with great beer! Cheers!
Jodie T.
Feb 15, 2025
We were finally able to get in to this local pizza shop. It's almost impossible to get inside on the weekends. You can't even park! (They do have a drive thru window). When you go inside you order at the counter then they'll call your number when your order is ready. I remember this was part of the reason we also left before because it was extremely crowded and people were standing everywhere. So if you don't like that sort of thing then the weekends aren't for you. We went during the week and about 4 pm. It wasn't crowded at all. We walked in and ordered immediately. The staff was very friendly. We noticed a sign on the wall saying they've been around since 1972. We ordered their large pizza and an order of fries. We were surprised that their largest pizza is 14". The price was over $14. That surprised us because most pizza shops are selling 16-18" pies. We ordered plain cheese so we could taste it without extra stuff on it. It's good. I wasn't wowed by it but it's definitely good. We both areed the fries were amazing! I'd definitely ordered those no doubt!! They have a great location right in the tourist section of Gettysburg. If you're on a tour and looking for pizza, I'd definitely give them a try.
Read More
Trish L.
Jan 1, 2025
Tried Tommy's for a late lunch/early dinner on a Thursday around 330-4pm. You order first at the counter and then seat yourself until your number is called to grab your food from the front. We had been recommended both the pizza and the cheesesteak. We asked for only meat, cheese, and sautéed onions on the cheesesteak and the pizza was all extra cheese with half bacon. The staff were pleasant and easily understood the order. It was about $35 including a bottle of water. The seating area has both booths and tables with a variety of seating capacities. The tables were mostly clean, a few crumbs here and there. The food was out within 15 minutes and was piping hot. The pizza was my favorite. Both the cheese and the sauce had great flavor. I loved the crust. The roll of the cheesesteak was toasted, which was fine until you got to the butt end of the roll and it's hard as a rock/inedible.
Read More
Ron B.
Nov 11, 2024
Try the Greek pizza and one of their draft beers. I actually had a brew that was made right here in Gettysburg! 100%
Read More
Jenny B.
Jun 9, 2024
Wonderful servers! The pizza is out of this world. I like the yummy pizza sauce. And I must say the sauce to cheese ratio is abundant. :) I often get the black olive & hamburger or the black olive & onions. Their Steak & cheese sub is super yummy, I love their fries! Their onion rings are tasty as are their salads. I enjoy the Greek salad and the club salad myself. :) I seriously crave food from this place. You can get to go or carry out. It's quite a popular place. When I was there today there was a little girl there having a birthday pizza party. Go!
Read More
Trina L.
Oct 30, 2023
We were staying at local campground. We tried to csll order in but no one answered the phone. So we drove there. There is on-site parking. First time trying. It was Saturday evening, very busy. We ordered 2 pizzas, cheese and pepperoni along with hot and mild wings. About 15 minutes wait for order. Not bad. We walked across the street to Bantam Coffee for drinks. Order done on time. Pizza delicious. Flavorful. I preferred regular wings over the hot ones. They had more flavor. Glad I tried them. Not on my top 10 for wings but good.
Read More
Jim S.
Sep 29, 2024
Boggles my mind to see this place isn't 5 stars across the board. Their pizza is so damned good. It's legitimately so good we drive up from DC pretty regularly to enjoy it. The poor reviews complaining about no parking or that it's too busy? It's Gettysburg, not NYC. Plenty of parking nearby or walk from your hotel. And too busy? That's not a problem to rate a business for, rather to congratulate them! I know we'll be there for Christmas festival weekend but hope to make it up a couple times before then too. Top quality food and the team busting their butts behind the counter are all super nice! Thank you, Tommy's Pizza!
Read More
Jesse A.
Nov 10, 2024
Amazing pizza top notch staff grade a++++++ always a must when visiting Gettysburg they are just printing money at this joint
Read More
Dawn S.
Jun 24, 2024
I have wanted to try this place for years. We finally decided to take the plunge and try it out. It was very busy, which is a good sign. My husband and I each ordered subs. He got the bacon cheeseburger. He said it was great. I got the turkey and mine was good as well. The french fries were nothing special, but they were manageable. The star of the visit was the super nice lady at the drive-through window. She was so sweet and 100% would be why I would come back. We had our pup with us and she gave her a treat. I can't say enough about her customer service. In today's entitled world, this is not the norm. She really made me feel like a valued customer. I will definitely return, if for nothing else than the customer service.
Read More
Dane S.
Dec 15, 2023
The best pizza in Gettysburg, in my opinion at least. I honestly have only had the pizza and few sides like fries and wings but that's because it's that good. I don't need to try anything else. I don't live near here anymore so any time I'm in town I have to get a pizza. Decent amount of parking on site for Gettysburg. They also have a drive thru window which is nice. They are always busy when I'm there so you know it's good. Staff are always nice and the food comes out quickly, they know what they are doing and how to handle a crowd.
Read More
Wendy P.
Mar 23, 2024
I got a pineapple Stromboli and my husband got the meat lovers. They were amazing. They offer containers of garlic and other seasonings which is nice. Order at the counter then sit inside or outside and they call your number. Baked fresh but didn't take forever. They have a parking lot but it's small. Within walking distance of a lot of hotels and B & B and in this historic area. Clean bathroom. Serve yourself fountain beverages that you can refill (nice on a hot day!). Nice, efficient people working there.
Read More