Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

This was a phone in, pick up order.Wanted to give Pizza Garden a try as it has been several years since we last ordered and I must say, the pizza did not disappoint The nice thing is when you place your order and you get there you can go through a drive-through window and the staff member was extremely friendly and very nice to talk to . Those days are very bad weather. This is a bonus that you do not have to leave your vehicle..We ordered a large traditional pizza with extra cheese, pepperoni and, Italian sausage and let's say it was full of flavor. Done to perfection with a very nice crust. .We look forward to our next order and will give their subs a try and possibly a dinner .The inside looked really nice nothing fancy, but extremely clean and very presentable .

All I can say is this pizza is absolutely amazing!!!! Honestly, it had been a few years since we ordered from the Pizza Garden and started ordering again a few months ago. I really don't recall why we stopped ordering, but so glad that we stopped by and ordered their pizza. Everything about their pizza is just so delicious. My husband says the inside is like an "old school" pizza shop, plenty of seating and windows. We typically order our food to go, but would love to order a dinner some time and sit down there for dinner. My husband said he saw their shrimp alfredo dinner being served and it also looked amazing!!!! They are always very prompt with service and very friendly!!!

The only place to get fantastic pizza in New Oxford. Well it might not be the only place but it is one of the best Pizzas. Nice thin crust with a delicious sauce. The take out window is quick and convenient.

On Wednesday my husband and I went here to eat. I really like their pizza and wanted to bring him here to try for the first time. The restaurant was busy but not excessive. The customers were coming in far enough apart that they weren't slammed. There appears to be only one waitress here. Unless I happened to come on only her days working. She's not the friendliest. We received our pizza and my husband asked if he could please have some Parmesan cheese. she looked at him and told him it was on the counter to get it himself. Not good! She could've responded so many different ways. Hang on, I'll be with you in a minute. I'd have even settled for, I can help you in a minute or IF YOU LIKE it's sitting on the counter if you want to help yourself. Please rethink before responding. No one is beneath helping themselves if asked appropriately. I'll stick to carry out IF I choose to return

This place has excellent Pizza, subs and strombolis. The Staff is friendly. Highly recommend this small town pizza place

Best pizza, subs, strombolis etc. When I have out of town company and they want something Italian, we always order carry out. Everyone loves it. Best onion rings too.

This is a small town pizza shop that is locally family owned. Very nice service. With made from scratch pizza and pasta sauce. The food over all is good not great. It is a place would cone bace to. It is better than some other small town pizza shops

Surprisingly bland. Pizza by the slice is always a good idea and the sizes of the slices here are big and worth the price but the quality leaves something to be desired. The crust is good but everything else is just really bland. If you order extra toppings, they just pile it on top of an already made pizza and heat it up. Service is very slow, even if nobody else is in there.

They make everything fresh I don't know how they only have 3.5 star they sh have at least 4.0 star in my opinion they have a lot of different stuff you will not be disappointed

i called and asked for a blt to go and I kinda got screamed at saying that they don't make them than got hung up on after I said I got 2 last week from there.