Michaelangelo's Pizza

I visited Michaelangelo's Pizza on a whim today, completely accidental. My goal was to grab some chicken from a deli nearby, and as I was parking, noticed someone walking on the sidewalk with a box of pizza in hand, and called an audible. I'm glad I did. There wasn't anyone inside of Michaelangelo's, which was awesome because it gave me time to meet Cara(sorry if I'm mispelling), who was just the friendliest, and despite having a migraine, made me feel extremely welcome. Her customer service was worth visiting again. The pizza being amazing is the icing on the cake. I got the Hungry Man which comes with pepperoni, ground beef, and steak, and informed them that I'd have to have the pepperoni removed because I don't eat pork. Cara informed me that they don't use pork products, only beef! It literally brought a tear to my eye. The pizza was delicious. The sauce, the toppings, just a really good pizza. You can tell they know what they're doing. I also got a piece of strawberry crunch cake that was top tier as well. I promised Cara that I'd be a regular at Michaelangelo's, and I meant that. As long as the customer service is what it was today, I'll be coming back again and again.

I love this pizza spot. They are open late and serve delicious food, especially when you're inebriated The staff is always professional and you can count on your food being fresh! The decor gives carryout, yet clean and organized!

I just called to place an order and was told that I'd have to come in-person to place an order. That was the most absurd thing I've ever heard from a pizza place. Never ordering from there again which is unfortunate because this was our go to pizza place for so long.

I've had several types of pizzas from here and all were great. I usually order wings to go and they are ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. He doesn't fry them to hard and the wings themselves are seasoned and crispy I will get different sauces depending on my taste try hat day. This isn't a sit down place more of just get it and go, but the food has always been good to me. I did have a sub a few months ago and the was also pretty good.

I used to be a fan of Michaelangelo's, but I think it's gone downhill. I ordered an extra large cheese pizza & two sodas for my roommate and I, but they brought us the wrong sodas, 2 diet coke instead of 1 diet coke, 1 coke. Then I was very surprised that when I lifted the very first slice it was very flimsy. I even checked to make sure the dough had fully cooked, it had, but it the cheese itself was thicker than the crust. The foundation was soft and not very appetizing, but we were starving and hadn't had much, and we already spent the money. Regardless a very disappointing experience, especially when it took a full hour to arrive. (They used to come closer to 35-40 minutes with really good pizza!)

If I could give less than 1 star I would. The order never showed and when I called the restaurant they wanted to give me a $5 credit. The manager was nasty and not helpful at all. The last order you will ever see from this customer I guarantee it.

So I came to this place by default. I was at Be Free Fridays at the Eubie Blake center and their caterers was on a hiatus. I needed somewhere to go because my stomach was in my back! I ordered my food when I walked in. I didn't really have a taste for pizza but I had to cure my hunger pains. The Customer Service was decent. I was greeted by someone and I asked them what was good? She said everything. I ordered some okay wings. They gave me all drums. I don't know if that as a good or bad thing but you may need to requests flats if that's what you like. They were really good too. I must admit. I ordered a Large pizza too. The food came out in less than 8 minutes so that was impressive.The funniest thing that happened was I checked in on YELP and it said that I get free breadsticks with my check in. I let the cook know and he act like he saw the ghost of Tupac. He was confused and he said well that's only when you order online. and I said well why would Yelp say that if it's false? " Sir if you don't go make my damn breadsticks" Any way I got my breadsticks. They were good and a day later I am actually eating them now and they are just as amazing as the first day.

A disappointing experience. The sub I ordered must've ended up in somebody else's house because the one they delivered to me wasn't what I ordered. A cheeseburger sub with lettuce, tomato, pickles, raw and fried onion is not a hamburger sub with raw onions, mayo and bbq sauce which is what they delivered. I also requested my fries well done, which they weren't. Only positive note was the chocolate cake, which was amazing. Shame the rest of this order was a nightmare. Sorry, Mich, but no masterpiece was experienced.

The worst new management. Very nasty disposition. It's dirty and you would think they would care but after ordering I realized if I want to be sicken with disease I shouldn't.I ordered online and they thought I was door dash. When I told them I wasn't it was like your black so of course you are a door dash. Most insulting.

I ordered the 12 buffalo wing combo. Good price, the food was great, and hot! Love how they closed off most of the store to ensure people don't hang out. The old store used to be full of homeless, drunks, and drug addicts.