Mamma Lucia of College Park
Mamma Lucia of College Park
Mama's Own Tiramisu!!!
Fettuccine alla Bolognese D
Excessive oil needed to drain produced from pasta
the dining area
Fettuccine alla Bolognese D
Logo sign (inside)
Spicy Penne (add meatballs and onions!!!)
14" New York Style Pizza Garden Salad
Chicken Alfredo with Caesar Salad
Spicy Penne (add meatballs and onions!!!)
Baked ziti lunch size. Very tasty.
Fabulous grilled salmon and sautéed spinach. Simple. Delicious. Allergy friendly with only oil, salt, and garlic. 10 out of 10 recommend
1/4 of oil removed from heating up next morning
Mama's Own Tiramisu!!!
Penne Vodka Sauce D
Pizza by the Slice, Fresh out of the Oven!!!
Shrimp Linguini (dinner portion!!!)
Seafood Salad
Garlic bread with olive oil.
Specials
Oh and there's delicious bread. First round is on the house (at least it was when I visited )
Spaghetti con Salsicce/Sausage (add onions!!!)
Fried Risotto Balls!!!
Lasagna (Dinner portion!!!)
Isaac W.
Jan 2, 2025
Worst meal that I can remember. I generally have enjoyed the pizza and my wife considers them the second-best pasta in the area, but we had maybe the worst, most bland, bordering on suspiciously inept dining experience in a long time.We ordered a cheese pizza and chicken marsala and both were nearly inedible from a taste perspective and in the case of the pasta, from maybe in terms of safety.The pizza: Bland, bordering on stale crust, with a sauce that at best could be described as flavorless and cheese that was skimped on so badly that that I thought we had ordered a Connecticut red pie. There was a distinct lack of any classic Italian flavors (rosemary, garlic, basil) or even salt. I'm not going to say that the box would have tasted better, but gnawing for comparison did pass my mind.The Chicken Marsala: A similar blandness that lacked any robust flavors associated with that dish. Small mushrooms and not enough sauce. The worst part was the actual chicken, nothing to give is any distinctness (breading, bronzing marinade) other than a sliminess that was unsettling. It was just several sad, pale rubbery chicken.It was take out and maybe a less than enthusiastic staff, stuck working on New Years Day, but it's an experience that left us turned off for the foreseeable future. Not sure if we'll go back anytime soon and not sure what I would advise except maybe dining in so if something is off, then you can bring it up to the staff in person, but for two meals at more than $50, I would hope that management would want to get it right.The Caesar salad that came with the pasta was fine.
Read More
Chris M.
Jul 29, 2024
This place is the go to place for pizza at work. We went for lunch last Friday. I ordered the baked ziti and Mike ordered the steak and cheese sandwich. The waitress brough garlic bread with a small container with olive oil. After a bit our food arrives. The portion was bigger than I expected for a lunch size. Mike's sandwich was fresh bread, lots of toppings and tasty steak. The ziti was full of cheese and tasty sauce. Definitely a repeat.
Read More
Katie L.
Jan 26, 2025
We came into Mamma Lucia on a whim after a basketball game - what a delight. The food was some of the best we had and the service was impeccable. The prices seemed a little high at first, but when we saw the quantities and quality of all the dishes, it was well worth it. Point of note - penne with vodka sauce was the best we'd ever had. My daughter was impressed with the fresh herbs throughout her dish. The family agreed that this is a spot we'd travel to (we live about an hour away) for a special dinner here in the future.
Read More
Alma G.
May 13, 2024
Came here in hopes that it would be just as good as Gaithersburg location. Was very disappointed. I had to take pictures for proof because this is unacceptable. We only waited for 12-14 minutes for our food so I thought that's good, but very small amount for sure. We took a look at the pizzas and they looked a little dry and old. Went home and ate it but it was lacking so much flavor. A little bit of pepper flakes was added to the bread but it was stale and hard to chew so definitely threw that out. Decided to save the rest for next day. Heated it up on the pan and was very disgusted. All the Alfredo sauce disappeared and literally.... turned into oil. My partner ordered chicken Parmesan and his lacked flavor too...For 2 entrees totaling up to $55 this was not worth paying for it. Definitely not coming back.
Read More
Lloyd D.
Mar 5, 2024
We stopped to get something to eat before a MD basketball game. The place we usually go closed so we tried Mamma Lucia.We were seated quickly and waited on just as fast. Server was great. Friendly and patient. Seemed to be the only one there but didn't make people wait even though he had a tough table. We were brought a bread with oil that was a little odd and we ordered a margarita pizza. Pizza wasn't anything special. Review is mainly for the good service.
Read More
Vicky S.
Jan 3, 2025
The food quality and quantity was horrible! Owner offered to buy me lunch instead of a refund.
Read More
Elizabeth O.
Jan 3, 2025
We come here regularly and food is always so good! Katherine was our waitress today and she was AMAZING super attentive and would check on us regularly. You can clearly see she enjoys her job.
Read More
Tony S.
Oct 22, 2024
Great tasting and authentic Italian food...if you're in the area you should definitely try the pasta dishes. The pizzas looked great and everyone around us was ordering them but it was a pasta night for us. Seafood Pasta special and the baked ziti. We timed it perfectly to watch UMD beat USC in the Homecoming game with the staff
Read More
Whitney L.
Jun 11, 2024
We used to love going to ML for pizza/pasta. The ambiance was never great - more like a cafeteria than a restaurant. The pizza used to be good. Sadly, the food has gone way down hill and the prices only go up. We ordered take out tonight and the pizza was undercooked, cold and had chewy canned mushrooms all over it. I hope it improves, but we won't be back.
Read More
D. K. G.
Aug 27, 2023
We enjoyed our pizza, tiramisu, and the service.The pizza was delicious and ver cheesy and great amount of meat toppings for a slice. The tiramisu was devine the mascapone filing was delicious. Ethan was a good server.
Read More
